Medieval II polishes Rome's formula instead of reinventing it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics argued over progress, not quality
Critics barely argued about whether Medieval II: Total War was good. They argued about whether it was new. IGN said it wasn't as revolutionary as its predecessor, but that it adds some new ideas and builds on others from Rome: Total War, and that this alone was reason enough to buy it. Hyper's Anthony Fordham praised its "incredible gameplay" on both the battlefield and the world map, then faulted it for being a refinement rather than a "huge leap forward."
That split tells you more about the game than its score does. Nobody disputed how well it plays. The open question was how much it should lose for sitting so close to the game before it. Across the 13 critic reviews behind its 86/100 aggregate, the quality of play counted for more than the lack of novelty. The critic average of 8.6 is computed from those critic reviews.
What the refinement looks like on the campaign map
The changes are in the details, and they add up. The turn-based campaign starts in the 1080s and offers seventeen playable factions. Some others stay dormant or absent at the start and appear later. You manage armies, fleets and agents across a large map, and you choose to fight each battle yourself or have the result calculated automatically.
The biggest structural change is the settlement split:
- Cities lean toward buildings that grow the economy.
- Castles lean toward buildings that let you recruit better soldiers.
- Most settlements can be converted from one type to the other, so the map becomes a set of choices about money versus troops.
Family members govern settlements and lead armies, and stats like Piety, Loyalty and Command shape how well they do. Religion also matters. Catholic, Orthodox and Muslim factions deal with unrest when a settlement doesn't share the state faith. Catholic rulers answer to a Pope who can excommunicate them or call Crusades, and imams with high Piety can declare jihads.
Win conditions come in two lengths. The short campaign asks you to defeat one or two rivals and hold at least 15 settlements. The long one asks for 45 territories plus one or two major cities such as Jerusalem, Rome or Constantinople.
Where the praise went highest
The most enthusiastic critics praised the stories the game produces, not its new features. Computer Games Magazine named it the eighth-best computer game of 2006 and argued that no scripted scene could match the stories players write as their armies advance. Edge put it at #26 on its list of the 100 best games to play today, calling it "as complete a depiction of war" as any video game had managed.
Historian Peter Englund, reviewing for Dagens Nyheter, found its battles "amazingly similar to an engraving from the 1600s."
PC Gamer (US) gave it an Editor's Choice Award, and the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for Strategy Game of the Year. GameSpot summed up the case for it as "epic, engrossing gameplay."
Who comes out ahead, and the rough edges
The refinement complaint matters most to players who already know Rome: Total War well. For them, Medieval II is a richer version of a familiar loop: the same campaign-plus-battle structure with castles, cities and the Pope added. For anyone new to the series, the complaint hardly applies. You get a mature version of the formula, and the earlier games it improves on aren't required reading.
The flaws critics did agree on are more practical:
- Pathfinding bugs on the battlefield.
- Some problems with the AI.
- A few new features that some reviewers found uninteresting.
- GameSpot's warning about "beefy system requirements," which was a complaint about PC hardware in 2006.
It's rated Teen and PEGI 16. Feral Interactive's 2016 ports put it on macOS and Linux alongside Windows.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Medieval II: Total War en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q629626 wikidata.org