Analysis · MediEvil

MediEvil's remake keeps the 1998 charm and the 1998 frustrations

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A charming story wrapped around sloppy combat

The best thing critics said about MediEvil and the worst thing came from the same review. IGN's Travis Northup called its "relentlessly charming story" the game's greatest strength. He also called the combat "sloppy and disorienting." That split runs through nearly every review of this 2019 PlayStation 4 remake.

The scores reflect it. MediEvil holds a 67 on Metacritic from 72 critics and 67% on GameRankings, which both sites count as mixed or average. The critic average of 6.9 is calculated from those critic aggregates using a published formula. It sits where you'd expect for a game that critics liked to look at more than they liked to play.

Players still showed up. MediEvil was the fifth-best-selling game in the United Kingdom in its launch week. On November 5, 2019, it ranked third for the week on a combined download and retail chart covering 43 countries.

The look is the part critics agreed on

Other Ocean Emeryville rebuilt the game, and Sony Interactive Entertainment published it. The original was made by SCE Cambridge Studio for the PlayStation in 1998. Critics praised the visual design for staying faithful to that original while adding detail. Northup singled out the extra personality in both the visuals and the audio.

GameSpot's James Swinbanks also praised the characters and the visual style. GamesRadar+ and VideoGamer.com agreed on the visuals too. The setting and Sir Daniel Fortesque himself, a skeletal knight you guide across the land of Gallowmere, came through as the remake's clearest strengths.

Why the old design hurts more now

The remake keeps the original's content almost unchanged. Critics found that much of that design feels dated, and the biggest complaint was the lack of checkpoints. Lose all your health partway through a level and the game ends. Your health doesn't refill on its own between levels either. Life Bottles will top you back up once the bar is empty, but only if you have one.

Some of the punishment is sharper than that. Falling into water kills Dan instantly, and critics said controls and a camera they considered unreliable made those deaths worse. Swinbanks wrote that the sloppy controls and camera make even basic tasks harder than they should be.

Destructoid's Chris Carter warned that the combat "might be a little too retro for modern audiences," and compared it to older hack-and-slash games such as Golden Axe.

Carter also expected that anyone who disliked the original wouldn't like this version. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner found the combat imprecise. He ranked MediEvil below other remakes of the same era, including Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy and Spyro Reignited Trilogy.

What the remake adds on top of the original

The structure is the same as before. You pick levels from a map of Gallowmere and fight with swords, clubs, throwing daggers and bows. Many of those weapons can be charged for a stronger hit, and a shield blocks a limited amount of damage. With no weapon equipped, Dan can attack with his own arm, either up close or by throwing it. Green gargoyle heads offer hints, and blue ones sell ammunition for gold.

Each level hides a chalice of Souls that fills as you defeat enemies. Collecting it opens the Hall of Heroes, where characters hand out new weapons and items. If you collect every chalice, you see the true ending.

The remake adds a few features on top of that:

  • switching between a primary and a secondary weapon, borrowed from MediEvil 2;
  • the "Dan Cam," an optional over-the-shoulder camera;
  • the Book of Gallowmere, a reference guide to characters and enemies;
  • optional "Lost Souls" missions from a ghost in each level. Completing all of them unlocks the original game in the menu as "Old Game."

None of these additions change the complaints above. The Dan Cam is a new viewpoint, but critics still faulted the camera. That makes the Lost Souls reward the most interesting addition here, since it lets you play both versions side by side.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet