Analysis · Call of Duty: Modern Warfare

Modern Warfare's reboot traded arcade speed for tension, and mostly won

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A sixteenth entry that starts its sub-series over

Modern Warfare is the sixteenth Call of Duty and a reboot of the Modern Warfare sub-series. Infinity Ward developed it, Activision published it, and it came out on October 25, 2019, for PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Windows. Rather than add another layer to the formula, it rebuilds the series around slower, more deliberate fighting. You clear rooms, breach doors and read who is a threat before you pull the trigger.

Critics mostly backed the change. Metacritic lists "generally favorable reviews" on every platform, and the critic aggregates for the game sit between 77 and 81 out of 100. The critic average, computed from those aggregates, is 7.9. Looking back, critics regularly place it in the top five or top ten games in the franchise and credit it with reviving the series.

A campaign that grades your restraint

The biggest change is in the single-player campaign. At the end of each level, a threat assessment grades you from A to F based on how many civilians you hurt or kill, and higher grades earn rewards. Some moments hinge on a split-second read: in one, a woman who seems to be reaching for a gun is actually lifting her baby from a crib. What characters say changes with the choices you make.

The tactical options go further than past entries. One sniper mission lets you take objectives in any order across a large map. During breaching and clearing, you can shoot out the lights and fight with night-vision goggles. Critics called it one of the best campaigns in the franchise, pointing to its memorable missions, its tone and its set pieces, which recalled older games in the series.

Where the realism ran into trouble

The campaign's ambitions drew the sharpest criticism. After its showing at E3 2019, the game was criticized for including child soldiers and for letting you shoot civilians, infants among them. IGN called it the most divisive game of the event. Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw described the demo as "cold intense ruthless killing."

Emma Kent of Eurogamer singled out a level where the player appears to control a child soldier. She felt it turned sensitive material into a boss fight, calling it "a Frankensteinian, dissonant mess." She praised a stealth mission inside a building as a good look at how terrorists hide among civilians, while finding its emphasis on avoiding collateral damage heavy-handed. Cade Onder of GameZone argued that one civilian in a scene gives only the illusion of choice, and that the game's linear structure may hold back its storytelling.

The threat assessment is a real idea, but critics weren't convinced the levels around it give you enough room to make it matter.

The game was also pulled from Russia's PlayStation Store. Sony said in October 2019 that it would not be sold there.

Multiplayer gained new modes and brought back killstreaks

Online play follows the same tactical lean. Maps reward exploration and door breaching. A Hardcore "Realism" mode removes the HUD entirely. The mini-map was cut at first, then restored after the beta, though enemies still don't show as red dots unless someone calls in a UAV killstreak.

  • Gunfight: two-on-two rounds lasting forty seconds.
  • Ground War: matches with over 100 players.
  • Killstreaks are back in place of the Scorestreaks of recent entries, and a perk called "Pointman" converts them back.
  • Deep weapon customization: most guns offer up to 60 attachments, with five equipped at once.

Critics praised the reworked gunplay. Chris Freiberg of Den of Geek wrote that each weapon has "some real weight." The changes cost it some goodwill, though. Critics objected to the removal of the Prestige system, to play that encourages camping, and to weaker map design. Dan Wenerowicz of Complex went further and argued that the push toward grounded play made later Call of Duty games worse.

Zombies is gone for the first time since Call of Duty: Ghosts in 2013. In its place, Special Ops returns: four large Operations that require a full four-player co-op squad, plus smaller Classic missions. Its Survival mode was a PlayStation 4 timed exclusive until October 2020. The game also laid the groundwork for Warzone, which became a major part of the franchise.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet