Naughty Dog's remake of The Last of Us rebuilds everything except the story
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A remake that changes everything but the script
Critics described one main idea behind Naughty Dog's 2022 remake: rebuild the 2013 game from the ground up and keep the story exactly as it was. The narrative is unchanged, the map layouts are the same, and the original's online multiplayer is gone. The new work went into how the game looks and moves, how enemies think, and who is able to play it. Most of what critics said comes down to whether that trade is enough.
The story is still the one players know. Joel escorts a young girl, Ellie, across a post-apocalyptic United States. Along the way they fight hostile humans and the Infected, cannibalistic creatures carrying a mutated strain of the Cordyceps fungus. The 2014 expansion Left Behind is included, remade too, and follows Ellie with her best friend Riley.
The faces are where the rebuild pays off
Several reviewers called the new character models and facial animation the remake's greatest feature. IGN's Luke Reilly and EGM's Michael Goroff both said the new microexpressions make the acting land harder. Game Informer's Blake Hester found the performances more emotive without the original's awkwardness. Shacknews put it most simply: the characters "look far less doll-like."
The faces show the remake's central idea working at its best. The script didn't change, but critics felt it finally reads the way it was meant to. Video Games Chronicle's Jordan Middler said the remake captures story moments the original couldn't manage on the hardware of its time. Lighting drew similar praise. The Telegraph's Dan Silver called it award-worthy, and Goroff noted that the more realistic light never broke the story's tone.
Smarter enemies, same rooms
Here the idea runs into its limits. Enemy and companion AI were overhauled, with more characters on screen and enemies that act more aggressively and tactically. GameSpot's Jake Dekker found encounters tenser and harder because of it. The Washington Post's Gene Park praised the realistic gunplay and called Joel's movement "appropriately heavy."
The levels themselves weren't touched, though, and critics noticed. Siliconera's Josh Tolentino called the AI changes superficial because the maps and encounter designs are identical. Goroff found enemy behavior still simplistic. Ars Technica's Sam Machkovech said the game at its worst "still feels like a PlayStation 3 game." Several reviewers also missed the dodge move from Part II, and Hardcore Gamer saw companions still taking wrong paths.
Better controls in old rooms: critics agreed the combat improved on the original, and most agreed it still trails Part II.
Accessibility is the addition nobody disputes
If critics questioned other changes, they didn't question this one. GameSpot's Dekker wrote that it "sets a new standard for accessibility in games." The A.V. Club's William Hughes called the accessibility options the only worthy addition. The options include:
- customizable controls and a screen reader
- audio prompts and audio description for cutscenes
- haptic feedback during dialogue
- difficulty settings that adjust enemy resilience, stealth and resources separately
Can I Play That? praised the range but flagged some mobility problems and how fiddly it is to balance the options against each other. On PlayStation 5, critics ranked the controller's haptics among the best uses yet. The 3D audio made the Infected scary enough that one reviewer turned the sound off entirely.
The case against paying twice
The common complaint follows from the same idea. Because the story is untouched, several reviewers questioned whether the remake needed to exist, given its price and the existence of The Last of Us Remastered. GameRevolution's Jason Faulkner called the lack of story additions "some huge missed opportunities." Hester argued that leaving the narrative alone makes its themes feel more dated next to the modern visuals. Critics also regretted losing the multiplayer.
The platform matters too. The PlayStation 5 version averaged 88/100 across 123 reviews, while the Windows version sat at 59/100 across 31. The critic average, calculated from critic aggregates, is 8.0.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Last of Us Part I en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q113377532 wikidata.org