NBA 2K22 scored well with critics, but only 59% would recommend it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Good scores, half-hearted recommendations
The split on NBA 2K22 isn't between critics who loved it and critics who hated it. It's between the average score and how many reviewers were willing to say "buy it." One aggregate counted 77 reviews as of October 19, 2021. It put the average at 76/100, but only 59% of those critics recommended the game.
That gap is the most telling number here. A 76 average usually describes a solid game. A 59% recommendation rate means a large share of the critics who scored it near that average still didn't think readers should pick it up.
Metacritic was kinder, at 78/100 across 11 reviews on each of the six platforms, which it labels "generally favorable." One outlet published a 7/10 on September 20, 2021. On these numbers, nobody called it a bad game.
A capable game that few critics got excited about
Scores like these usually describe an annual sports game that does its job without giving reviewers much to rave about. Most critics found it good enough to score well. Fewer found it good enough to push on readers who already owned the previous year's game, NBA 2K21.
The published reception doesn't spell out which parts held critics back, so it's best not to guess. What it does show is recognition from the industry. At the 25th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards, the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated NBA 2K22 for "Sports Game of the Year." Players kept coming back too: it sold over 10 million copies as of May 2022, and it appears among the most played games on Steam.
A high average with a low recommendation rate usually means "fine if you want this specific thing" rather than "everyone should play this."
The server shutdown changes the math
The online servers for NBA 2K22 shut down on December 31, 2023. Critics reviewed the game while those servers were running. Anything that depended on them no longer works, so the multiplayer modes that were part of the original package now offer much less.
That matters more than any score difference between outlets. A buyer today gets a narrower game than the one that earned a 76 to 78 average. The yearly series has also moved on since then: NBA 2K23 arrived in 2022, and the series has released a new edition every year through NBA 2K26 in 2025.
Who still has a reason to play it
Go back to the split. The critics who recommended it were probably the ones who wanted another year of NBA 2K and weren't asking for much more. That's still the reader it fits best today, with one more condition: they're happy to play alone.
- Offline single-player fans who already have a PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch or Windows PC and see it at a very low price.
- Families looking for a basketball game rated Everyone.
- Series collectors who want the 23rd installment for completeness.
If you want to play online against other people, this edition can't give you that anymore. Pick a newer entry instead.
Sources
- Wikipedia: NBA 2K22 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q107602058 wikidata.org