NBA 2K24 plays like real basketball, then charges you for everything around it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for the fan who cares how a possession feels
NBA 2K24 is for the basketball fan who wants a game to move like an NBA broadcast and who plans to spend most of their time on the court, not in menus. For that player, critics agreed it got the core right. IGN's Ben Volmer called the on-court play "fantastic" and said it felt like a real NBA experience. Even reviewers who were harsh on the rest of the package described the basketball as "authentic".
It's the 25th entry in the NBA 2K series. Visual Concepts developed it, 2K published it, and it came out worldwide on September 8, 2023, for Windows, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S and Nintendo Switch.
ProPLAY is the real upgrade, but only on some machines
The big new feature is ProPLAY, which takes real game footage and turns it into in-game animations. Volmer wrote that it made the game "stronger than ever", and it's the clearest reason this entry plays differently from NBA 2K23.
Which version you play matters. The PS5 and Xbox Series X/S versions got the new animation technology. The PC version didn't, and critics called that out. On Metacritic, the PS5 version scored 68/100 and the Xbox Series X version 67/100, both rated "mixed or average". Those two versions are the best case, and they still landed in the middle.
Where the same fan gets let down
The money side is what pulled the game down. IGN's review said the game scores with its gameplay but that its microtransaction tactics are a "costly turnover". The redesigned MyTeam market lets players buy any card, and that led to complaints that the mode is pay-to-win. If you enjoy building a team, that change works against you.
- At launch it became the second worst reviewed game on Steam, behind only Overwatch 2. Most of the anger was about rising microtransactions across the series.
- 2K's parent company, Take-Two Interactive, was sued over those practices.
- Steam users reported recurring bugs and errors, and said many of them had carried over from NBA 2K23.
Critics who wanted to like the game kept running into the same problem: the basketball is good, and the game keeps asking you to pay to enjoy it fully.
The online half no longer exists
NBA 2K24's online servers shut down on December 31, 2025.
Since that date, anything that needs 2K's servers can't be played. The game is a multiplayer title as well as a single-player one, so a large part of what critics reviewed is gone. The shutdown also removes the online card market at the center of the pay-to-win complaints, which leaves the on-court play that critics praised as the main thing left. That play is now available in newer entries that still have their online side.
The critic numbers already sat in the middle before the shutdown. One aggregate counted 70 reviews and found 35% of critics recommending the game. The critic average, calculated from the critic aggregates, is 6.6 out of 10.
Sources
- Wikipedia: NBA 2K24 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q120462057 wikidata.org