NBA 2K25 scored well with critics, but only about half came out clearly for it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A 75 average beside a 54% figure
The sharpest disagreement over NBA 2K25 doesn't show in its average score. One aggregate counted 69 reviews and landed at 75/100, a respectable number for a yearly sports game. The same aggregate's percentage figure, across 68 reviews, came in at just 54%.
Put those side by side and a pattern appears. Most critics scored the game as decent. Barely half of them, though, came down clearly in its favor. Reviewers agreed on how good the game was but split on whether that was good enough.
Metacritic shows a calmer picture. The PlayStation 5 version scored 79/100, the Xbox Series X version 77/100 and the PC version 76/100, all in the "generally favorable" band. With so little between the best and worst of those versions, which console you play on barely changes the critical verdict.
What that split says about who it suits
Critics' scores show that they disagreed but not exactly what they disagreed about. Still, the shape of the split is telling for a series on its 26th entry. When a game scores well across the board and only about half of critics come out clearly for it, the debate is usually about value, not quality. The real question is whether this year's version adds enough over last year's, which here means NBA 2K24.
That points to two kinds of players:
- Likely to be happy: people who want the current NBA season in a polished sim and buy into the series most years. To them, a steady, well-reviewed game is what they're paying for.
- Likely to feel short-changed: people who skip years and want a big jump before they pay full price again. For them, that narrow 54% figure is the warning sign.
Awards voters leaned toward the first group. NBA 2K25 was nominated for "Best Sports / Racing Game" at The Game Awards 2024 and for "Sports Game of the Year" at the 28th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.
The shutdown matters more than the scores now
The critics' debate has since been overtaken by dates. NBA 2K25 was delisted from digital storefronts on October 30, 2026, and its online servers shut down on December 31, 2026.
The game supports both single-player and multiplayer play, and the multiplayer half has an end date. The record doesn't say which features will keep working offline once the servers go dark. So anyone thinking about buying it now is paying for an unknown amount of game.
Once the servers are off, the multiplayer half of this game is gone.
Where it sits in a long series
Visual Concepts developed NBA 2K25 and 2K published it. It came out on September 6, 2024, for Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Windows, Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S. An Apple Arcade release for iOS, macOS and tvOS followed on October 3, 2024.
Players showed up in large numbers whatever critics thought. The game had sold 11.5 million units by August 2025, and it ranks among the most played games on Steam. Its critic average of 7.6, worked out from the critic aggregates, sits right where the reviews did: good, not exceptional.
The series has also moved on. NBA 2K26 arrived in 2025 as its successor, and with this entry's online life ending, that newer game is the one to look at if you want current NBA basketball.
Sources
- Wikipedia: NBA 2K25 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q127328619 wikidata.org