New World's aim-based combat kept players coming back as critics stayed split
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
An awards nod on one side, a 48% on the other
The best thing on record for New World is its nomination for Best Multiplayer Game at The Game Awards 2021. It has also spent several stretches among the most played games on Steam. The sharpest number against it is a 48% from an aggregate of 65 reviews dated November 19, 2024. The same count gives it 72/100.
Metacritic summed up the reception as "mixed or average." The Windows, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and Series S versions each sit at 67/100 across 13 reviews. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 7.0.
So players kept coming back to a game critics never fully warmed to. The split makes sense once you look at what the game asks of you.
Combat asks for aim, not a target lock
This is New World's strongest design choice. Attacks don't lock on, so you have to aim them yourself. As enemies level up, they get longer and harder attack sequences, and you answer with timed attacks, dodges, weapon blocks, retreats or crawling stealth. Mana, stamina and health are the resources you manage while you do it.
The weapon skill trees cover a wide spread:
- Melee: sword and shield, hammer, hatchet, great axe, spear, flail and great sword
- Ranged: bow, musket and blunderbuss
- Magic: fire staff, life staff, ice gauntlet and void gauntlet
That range explains why the game is listed as an action-adventure game as well as an MMORPG. If you find games built on tab targeting too passive, this is the part of New World built for you.
Crafting carries the game, and the upkeep costs gold
Trade skills come in three groups. Crafting covers weapon smithing, armoring, engineering, jewel crafting, arcana, cooking and furnishing. Refining covers smelting, woodworking, leather working, weaving and stone cutting. Gathering covers logging, mining, harvesting, and tracking and skinning. A separate camping skill handles wilderness survival.
Gold coins run the economy. You can sell unwanted items to other players on the market, salvage them for resources, trade directly or simply drop them. Characters don't lose items when they die. Instead, gear takes damage from every fight, every use and every death, and fixing it costs repair items plus gold.
That turns maintenance into a steady background chore. Players who enjoy gathering and trading will feed the loop happily. Everyone else may feel it as a time tax. Buying a house, which grants aesthetic and utility bonuses and a fast-travel point to its settlement, sweetens the deal for players who settle in.
Getting around was slow until 2023
For two years, Aeternum (a fantasy version of the Americas, set in the mid-seventeenth century, where everyone who arrives becomes immortal) had no mounts. The base game offers three quick-travel methods, skills that give short bursts of forward speed, climbing over most obstacles and using the fire staff to cross large gaps through the air.
Mounts finally arrived with the Rise of Angry Earth expansion on October 2, 2023: horses, dire wolves and lions, plus a Riding trade skill that unlocks faster speeds, buffs and attachments. A game that was delayed from May 2020 to August 2021 and finally launched on September 28, 2021 was still filling basic gaps two years later, which goes some way toward explaining why critics stayed lukewarm.
PvP stays opt-in
Players form groups of up to five and join one of three factions: the Marauders, the Syndicate or the Covenant. Factions compete to control settlements, and you can fight other players with or without questing.
PvP only applies when you choose a "flagged" state before leaving a settlement. It turns on after a 30-second cooldown, and you can only attack, or be attacked by, other flagged players.
Players who want to quest, craft and explore can stay out of player fights completely, and competitive players still get faction warfare. The age ratings are Teen and PEGI 16.
Sources
- Wikipedia: New World (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q61643718 wikidata.org