Overwatch cut a tank from each team, and it plays faster for it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One fewer tank, and everything else bends around it
Overwatch is built on one change: each team lost a player. The original 2016 game put six heroes on a side, two from each role. This version keeps the damage, support and tank roles but drops one tank slot in role queue, leaving five players per team. Game director Aaron Keller said the goal was speed. The team felt six-player matches had become slow, and fewer bodies would also mean less for players and spectators to track.
Removing a tank meant changing nearly everything else too:
- New maps have more cover to make up for less tank protection.
- Damage heroes move faster.
- Support heroes regenerate health passively.
- Tanks were redesigned to play more aggressively.
Two heroes changed the most. Orisa swapped several defensive abilities for offensive ones and became better at keeping herself alive. Doomfist moved from the damage role and was rebuilt as a fast-moving tank. Every hero from the first game is still here, along with new ones, bringing the roster past 40.
Critics said the change worked but cost some teamwork
Judged on that one idea, critics mostly said it succeeded. IGN's Simon Cardy wrote that five-on-five pulled the game out of the "stagnant meta swamp" the original had sunk into over its last couple of years. He also said it gave up some of the shine of the original's team play. That's the trade in short. A smaller team moves faster, but each player has less of a squad to lean on.
Asked simply whether it's fun, Cardy's answer was yes: still a great hero shooter, just not at the peak of its powers.
Destructoid's Chris Carter felt the same, writing that the charm was "still there" even if the game no longer had the first one's cachet. Scores sit in a narrow range, from 75 to 79 out of 100 across platforms, with one aggregate at 77 from 75 reviews. The critic average, calculated from those critic numbers, is 7.7. Critics agreed the game plays well. They just didn't think it was a landmark.
The free-to-play model undercut the fresh start
The faster format was meant to make Overwatch feel new. Critics said the way it makes money made it feel familiar in a bad way. GameSpot's Jessica Howard wrote that the series had gone from a genre-defining shooter to a "trend-chasing" one that felt more like other games. PC Gamer's Tyler Colp went further, saying the sequel seemed to be trying to "bury its predecessor alive" under Blizzard's commercial expectations.
Most of the specific complaints were about the switch from loot boxes to a battle pass:
- The new hero Kiriko was locked as a free reward on the first season's battle pass, so new players couldn't just pick her.
- Cosmetic prices in the shop drew criticism, along with how long it took to earn items without paying.
- Players and some journalists pointed out that many other battle passes give back enough currency to buy the next season's pass, and this one didn't.
Carter summed it up when he wrote that the game was no longer a premium product with characters you could easily jump in and out of. The PvE content that was supposed to fix that was later dropped, which Keller acknowledged.
Players took longer to warm up than critics did
On Steam, it went badly at first. Within 48 hours of the Steam release it was the worst-rated game of all time on the platform, and many outlets called it review bombing. The reasons included the cancelled PvE content, allegations of sexual harassment at Activision Blizzard, and lost access to local servers in China after Blizzard's agreement with NetEase ended. Nearly two-thirds of those reviews were written in Simplified Chinese.
Things improved over time. Season 15, in February 2025, added perks to the core modes and brought loot boxes back, and Steam reviews moved from "Overwhelmingly negative" to "Mixed." The game lost nearly 40% of its concurrent Steam players when Marvel Rivals launched in December 2024. Its Steam player count doubled after it was relaunched under the plain Overwatch name. It was also nominated for the British Academy Games Award for Multiplayer.
Keep the score in mind when you read that history. The core game earned it, and most of what went wrong happened around the matches, not in them.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Overwatch (2023 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q73163646 wikidata.org