Analysis · Oxygen Not Included

Oxygen Not Included rewards patient engineers and leaves newcomers to sink

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed it was good and split on who could handle it

Critics didn't argue about whether Oxygen Not Included works. Metacritic counted its reviews as generally favorable, and the critic aggregate lands at 80/100 from two reviews. The critic average is 8.0 out of 10. The real disagreement sat inside individual reviews: the depth that earned the praise was also the reviewers' main worry.

Nate Crowley at Rock Paper Shotgun praised the design and the way the game unfolds over time. He also asked whether its ever-growing complexity would push away more casual players, especially anyone without a background in science or engineering. GameCentral gave it 8/10 and praised its scientific accuracy and design, but flagged the difficulty and the lack of in-game learning tools.

So the open question isn't quality. It's whether the game's demands match what you want from a sim.

What the game asks of you

You start with three colonists, called duplicants, stranded inside an asteroid with no memory of how they got there. Only a few pockets have breathable air. You have to keep their hunger, waste and oxygen in check while turning that rock into a colony that can sustain itself.

Each world is procedurally generated and split into biomes, each with its own materials and alien critters. Past the starting area, many regions are vacuum or lack oxygen, so the duplicants need preparation before they go in. Disease and extreme temperatures add more pressure.

You never control a duplicant directly. You queue jobs and set priorities, and they work through them as well as their skills allow:

  • Order a run of wire, and they gather the material, clear the path and build it.
  • If nobody can reach the material, the job sits unfinished while they do other work.
  • Each duplicant has stats, prefers the tasks they're best at and improves with practice.

Why the physics is the draw and the hurdle

The detail critics kept coming back to is the simulation. Gases diffuse and atmospheres even out. Open a new natural chamber and the oxygen in rooms you already sealed can drop. Liquids drain downward under gravity. GameCentral singled out this accuracy for praise.

This is also where Crowley's warning applies. A system that behaves like real physics doesn't forgive guesses. If you don't know why air pressure equalizes or where water ends up, problems can arrive with no obvious cause. GameCentral's concern about missing learning tools points the same way: the game leaves the explaining to you.

The colony doesn't fail because a timer ran out. It fails because something you built followed the rules exactly.

Reading the split as a buyer's guide

Put the two reviews together and a clear profile emerges. If tracing a cause through several linked systems sounds satisfying, the praise for design and progression is aimed at you, and the complexity is the reward. If you'd rather learn by being taught, both critics' warnings land squarely on you.

The release history supports the case that the depth is deliberate. Klei ran the game in Steam early access from February 2017 before the full release on July 30, 2019, and it still finished with nominations for Strategy/Simulation Game of the Year at the 23rd Annual D.I.C.E. Awards and in Strategy/Simulation at the 2020 Webby Awards.

It's single-player only and runs on Windows, macOS and Linux. Expect a game that tests your understanding more than your reflexes, and that lets you fail without telling you why.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet