Analysis · Papers, Please

Papers, Please makes a border desk job feel like a moral trap

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who want pressure with a conscience

Papers, Please is for players who like small, exacting tasks under a clock, and who want those tasks to mean something. You play an immigration inspector at a border checkpoint in Arstotzka, a fictional country in 1982 that has just ended a six-year war with neighboring Kolechia. You never leave the booth. The whole game is the desk, the documents and the person standing on the other side of the glass.

If you enjoy spotting the one wrong date on a form, and you don't mind a story told almost entirely through paperwork, this was built for you. If you want action, exploration or a lot of variety from one session to the next, it wasn't.

Where the desk job delivers

The structure is simple and it tightens every day. Each in-game day brings new entry rules, and you check every arrival's papers against them before a real-time shift runs out. When something doesn't match, you can question the entrant, ask for missing documents, compare fingerprints or order a full body scan. Then you stamp the passport to approve or deny entry, or you call for an arrest. Break protocol and a citation arrives by fax a moment later.

Critics praised how immersive this loop is. CBC News' Jonathan Ore called it a "nerve-racking sleuthing game" with relentless pacing, and he noted that all of it happens at a desk job. Wired named it the top game of 2013. Its writers argued that the drab look and the bureaucratic title capture life as a low-level worker in a police state.

The pressure keeps building because the politics keep shifting. As relations with nearby countries get worse, new rules appear: whole nationalities turned away, new document types demanded. The scripted encounters mixed in with random entrants mean you can't settle into an easy rhythm.

Every kindness comes out of your family's budget

At the end of each day you're paid for every entrant you processed correctly, minus fines for mistakes, plus any bribes you took. Then you split that money between rent, food, heat and other basics for your family. Go into debt and the game ends.

That budget screen gives the moral choices their weight. Waving through a spouse with incomplete papers might reunite a couple, but it can also cost you a citation, and you might be letting in a terrorist. Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw of Zero Punctuation put it among his top five games of 2013 for exactly this reason. In his words, it makes it "really hard to be a good person".

The real choice, as Croshaw framed it, is between trying to make the world better and simply looking after your own family.

Simon Parkin, writing for The New Yorker, named it his top game of 2013 and called it "grim yet affecting". Patrick Begley of the Sydney Morning Herald described it as an "empathy game", one that asks you to live inside a character's emotional world.

Where it loses some players

The mechanic that hooks most critics is the same one that pushes others away. Stephanie Bendixsen of Good Game called it "tedious". She found the moral fallout interesting but was so bored by the checking itself that she struggled to get from one day to the next.

That criticism is fair to take seriously. There isn't a second activity to break things up. If the first few shifts feel like chores rather than puzzles, the later ones add more rules, not a change of pace.

Twenty endings give it a long tail

The story mode has twenty possible endings. They depend on how you handle a secret group called EZIC that's plotting a coup, and on whether you try to escape to neighboring Obristan, with or without your family. Unlockable endless modes with randomized entrants extend it past the story.

It's also easy to find. It started on Windows and macOS in 2013 and later came to Linux, iOS, PlayStation Vita and Android. Its awards back up the critical consensus, including Excellence in Narrative and Excellence in Design at the 2014 Independent Games Festival and a Peabody Award in 2021.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet