PaRappa the Rapper proves style can carry a game built on button timing
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A primitive idea, made to look brilliant
Next Generation summed up the game in one line: style over substance had "never been better done". That's the idea PaRappa is built on. The mechanic is about as basic as games get, and everything else exists to make you stop noticing.
A teacher raps a line. Symbols matching the lyrics scroll across a bar at the top of the screen. You press the matching buttons in time so PaRappa raps the line back. Do that through six stages and you've finished the game. Critics hailed it as a unique game with "irresistibly catchy" songs, and it's often called the first true rhythm game. Created by music producer Masaya Matsuura with artist Rodney Greenblat, it set out to win on presentation, not depth.
The meter is stricter than the cartoon art suggests
Under the bright look sits a fairly unforgiving scoring system. A "U Rappin'" meter ranks you as Awful, Bad, Good or Cool. Stay on beat and you hold at Good. Miss a line and a lower rank flashes. Miss two in a row and you drop a rank, and climbing back up takes two good lines in a row.
- To clear a stage, you must finish the song on Good.
- Ending on Bad or Awful, or falling below Awful at any point, fails the song and sends you back to the start.
- Only the first line of each pair changes your rank, so a missed second line won't drop you.
That last rule is the kind of hidden quirk that rewards players who study the system. Even so, the substance here is still timed button presses. The meter adds pressure, not variety.
Freestyling is where the substance hides
The deepest part of the game only opens up after you've beaten it once. Then you can chase a Cool rank by freestyling, rapping in a way that differs from the set lyric. Impress the game while Cool is flashing and the teacher leaves the stage, so you can rap freely for big points. Fail to impress twice in a row and the teacher comes back, dropping you to Good.
Finishing a stage on Cool earns a special ending, and clearing every stage on Cool unlocks a bonus mode with Katy Kat and Sunny Funny. This is the best answer to the charge that the game is thin. It's also locked behind a full clear, so many players will never see it.
Why the style won in 1996
Critics praised almost everything that sits on top of the mechanic. Dan Hsu of Electronic Gaming Monthly warned the tunes would stick in your head "for days". GamePro called the melodies "funk phenomenons". GameSpot singled out the "comically animated paper dolls" moving against colorful 3D backdrops, helped by smart camera work. Others praised the story and the title character.
The awards followed. It won Outstanding Achievement in Interactive Design and in Sound and Music at the first Interactive Achievement Awards in 1998. EGM named it Most Original Game of the Year and gave it Best Music, and PaRappa beat Lara Croft and Crash Bandicoot to Best Mascot. Players came too: 761,621 copies sold in Japan in 1997, making it the country's 7th best-selling game that year.
The one complaint critics shared was length. Six stages go by quickly, and style can't stretch that.
The PS4 remaster tests the idea and comes up short
The 2017 PS4 remaster drew mixed or average reviews, with a critic aggregate of 60/100 across 35 reviews. The critic average of 6.0 is computed from that aggregate. Reviewers liked that it kept the original's charm and sharpened the gameplay graphics, but noted that the cutscenes weren't improved.
The bigger problem: Destructoid's Caitlin Cooke reported "extremely noticeable lag" in every level and no calibration setting to fix it.
That cuts at the game's foundation. When the only real task is pressing buttons on time, lag breaks the deal that style is supposed to sweeten. Stuart Andrews of Trusted Reviews said he loved the character but that the game "no longer holds up". The charm survives the move to new hardware. The timing doesn't hold up as well.
Sources
- Wikipedia: PaRappa the Rapper en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1340462 wikidata.org