Analysis · Persona 3 Reload

Persona 3 Reload rebuilds a 2006 classic with Persona 5's comforts

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

An old story with every modern convenience added

The whole remake rests on one idea: keep Persona 3 as it was and rebuild everything around it to the standard set by Persona 5 (2016). IGN's Michael Higham summed it up as "a more fully realized version of a beloved RPG." Most of the praise, and most of the complaints, come back to how well Atlus followed that idea.

The story is unchanged. A high school student returns to his home city a decade after his parents died in a car crash. He learns he can summon a Persona, the physical form of his inner spirit, and joins the Specialized Extracurricular Execution Squad (S.E.E.S.) to fight Shadows and solve the mystery of the Dark Hour. Each day is split between social life and role-playing combat, and that split also survives.

Critics praised the remake for staying faithful. Its weakest points are where it stayed too faithful or left something out.

Where the Persona 5 polish shows

Many of the changes are small, and together they make the game much easier to follow. An objective line now sits under the date, time of day and moon phase, so you always know what the story needs next. The map is larger, shows more of the surroundings and marks important locations. The protagonist can now run.

Critics responded strongly to the interface. PlayStation Universe's Joe Richards called the blend of Persona 5's style with the original look a "masterclass in design" and praised "some of the most elegant menus in RPG history." IGN singled out the voice cast and the soundtrack.

The music did split opinion early on. Kenneth Shepard of Kotaku liked the pre-release demo but didn't like the remade music. Polygon's Chelsea Stark said the dungeons lacked environmental detail. She described them as faithful to the original but below what Persona 5 had set as the standard. This is the clearest case of the remake's idea pulling against itself, because a faithful dungeon can still look dated next to modern ones.

Dorm life is the biggest real addition

The Iwatodai Dorm, where the party lives outside of class, gains the most new content. The protagonist can now:

  • talk one on one with every dorm resident
  • cook food that restores the party in battle
  • tend plants on the roof, which teaches new battle Tactics
  • rent films to watch on the DVD player
  • borrow books from the school, which raises Academics

Like the at-home activities in Persona 4 and Persona 5, these raise Social Stats, which in turn open up Social Links. Doing an activity with a party member also gives combat buffs. This is where the remake does more than modernize: free evenings now feed into both the relationships and the fights.

What the rebuild left out

The remake is built on the original 2006 game, not on Persona 3 Portable. That means the option to play as the female protagonist from Portable is gone. Producer Kazuhisa Wada said Portable's added content was cut for budget reasons. Some critics and players objected, and fans released a mod, the Femc Reloaded Project, on February 19, 2024, shortly after launch.

Episode Aigis is the other sore point. It comes in the Expansion Pass rather than the base game. Before launch, critics were mixed to negative on that decision, partly because Wada had earlier called Reload a "complete experience." Fans review bombed the pass on Steam. After release, reviewers praised the expansion's plot and new music but called it "tedious" and repetitive, and faulted its controls.

The core game stands on its own. Treat Episode Aigis as optional, and if the female protagonist route matters to you, Persona 3 Portable is still the only official way to play it.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet