Analysis · Portal 2

Portal 2 grows its portal puzzles into a funny story and a standout co-op mode

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Better than perfect, or a game on rails

Eurogamer's Oli Welsh gave Portal 2 the highest praise a sequel can get. He called the original perfect and said the follow-up was not, because it was "something better than that." IGN's Charles Onyett went further and said it made the first game look like a prototype.

The sharpest complaint came from Peter Bright at Ars Technica. He found Portal 2 easier than its predecessor and said so many levels worked as tutorials that he felt "the game was on rails." He also missed the loneliness of the first game and called the constant chatter "inane babble" that broke the mood.

Both critics are describing the same choice. Valve took a short, quiet puzzle game and made it bigger, with more story, more tools and more talking. Most critics thought that worked. The aggregates (95/100 from 52 reviews, 94/100 from 40) back them, and the critic average comes to 9.6 out of 10.

New tools that teach themselves

The portal gun still opens two linked holes in suitable walls, and you still use them to reach the exit of each test chamber. The sequel adds lasers, tractor beams, Hard Light Bridges and launch pads called Aerial Faith Plates. All of them pass through portals. It also adds three paint-like gels: orange for speed, blue for bouncing and white to let a surface take a portal.

Critics mostly loved how these pieces arrive. The Telegraph's Tom Hoggins praised a learning curve built on "direction, rather than instruction." Wired's Chris Kohler said the puzzles never need overly complicated answers and often end in a forehead-slapping moment when the solution clicks. Time's Evan Narcisse worried the new elements would muddy the design and found they didn't.

The gels drew the most doubt. PC Gamer's Dan Stapleton found them hard to control and thought they had only a couple of real uses. Put that next to Bright's view that the game holds your hand, and the picture is a puzzle game that favors steady, satisfying progress over brutal difficulty.

The jokes carry the story

Most reviewers praised the writing and voice acting. Onyett credited Merchant's enthusiasm in the role and called the writing "consistently clever." Game Informer's Adam Biessener rated Johnson's character above GLaDOS and singled out "brilliant comedic timing." Stapleton could guess many plot twists but still wanted to see how the characters would react.

Not every story choice landed. Welsh called the attempt to recapture the original's end-credits song "a mistake." Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw said the campaign needlessly rewrote parts of the first game's story, even while calling it a "very good game."

Co-op is the part critics agreed on

The cooperative campaign puts two players in the roles of the robots ATLAS and P-Body, each with their own portal gun. Either player can use any portal. You can play split-screen on one console or online, and Windows, Mac OS X and PlayStation 3 players can team up across platforms. Built-in voice chat and gesture cues help partners coordinate.

Welsh called it "one of the most satisfying and genuinely collaborative" experiences you can share with a friend.

Onyett noted that the chambers don't just encourage teamwork; they require it. Even Croshaw, the campaign's harshest critic here, found the co-op more appealing and closer to the spirit of the original.

Where it stumbles

The second act moves into the old, less structured parts of Aperture, and several critics found it confusing. One said the difficulty jumps fast enough to put off casual players, with little sense of where to go between chambers. Kohler called the abandoned areas sterile, repeated and non-interactive.

  • Loading times between levels were long enough for one critic to notice and wish them shorter.
  • The same critic missed stand-alone test chambers and leaderboards, while still calling the game far from light on content.

None of these complaints pulled the scores down much. They describe a slower stretch and a few missing extras, not a broken game.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet