Puppeteer's stage-show charm split critics by 10 points
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A 10-point gap between the two critic tallies
Critics liked Puppeteer, but they didn't agree on how much. One aggregate, built from six reviews of the PlayStation 3 version, lands at 85/100. Another, counting 10 reviews, settles at 75/100. Metacritic calls the reception "generally favorable," and the critic average, computed from those critic tallies, is 8.0.
The published reception doesn't say what drove the spread. So the useful question is which parts of the design could pull one reviewer up and another down. The praise that is on record is specific: at the 17th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards, the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated the game for animation, art direction and original music composition. All three are about how the game looks and sounds, not how it plays. That points to a split between a presentation that earned industry recognition and a platformer whose systems are stranger than its storybook surface suggests.
A stage show first, a platformer second
Puppeteer is staged as a puppet show in front of an audience that laughs and cheers when something impressive happens. The story runs across seven acts, each split into three curtains. Kutaro, a boy turned into a puppet and promptly decapitated, works through them collecting shards of Moonstone, freeing the souls of other children and rescuing a goddess in distress.
That framing is the game's identity. If the theatrical delivery and the reacting crowd charm you, the rest follows. If they grate, there's no quieter mode to fall back on. This is a plausible reason for a 10-point gap: the presentation the D.I.C.E. nominations rewarded is also something a less charmed reviewer had to sit through in every act.
Heads are your health, and that cuts both ways
The smartest idea in the design is how damage works. Kutaro wears replacement heads, and each one unlocks its own animations tied to nearby scenery. Take a hit and the head flies off. Grab it back within a few seconds or it's gone. He can carry three, and losing all three sends him back to the last checkpoint. Collecting 100 Moonsparkles in a section earns an extra life.
The system forgives mistakes in the moment, which suits the Everyone 10+ and PEGI 12 ratings. Heads also double as collectibles. Each curtain has a set number of heads to find, souls to rescue and a hidden area to discover, and 100% completion means replaying old curtains with heads you pick up later. Completionists get a reason to go back. Players who want one pass and done will likely see that checklist as padding.
Scissors, champions and a second pair of hands
Getting around depends on Calibrus, a pair of magic scissors that lets Kutaro cut through parts of the scenery to reach areas he otherwise couldn't. Later he picks up the powers of the Four Champions of the Moon:
- the Knight's shield, which blocks damage and reflects attacks;
- the Ninja's bombs, for enemies and obstacles;
- the Pirate's hook, which grapples enemies and changes the scenery;
- the Wrestler's mask, for body slams and pushing or pulling obstacles.
A companion character searches the scenery for hidden objects, Moonsparkles and new heads. It starts as a ghostly cat named Ying-Yang and is later the fairylike Pikarina. With two players, the second person controls the companion. Alone, you steer Kutaro with one analog stick and the companion with the other.
That solo setup is the design choice most likely to divide players. It keeps the helper useful, but it asks one pair of thumbs to track two characters at once.
Who comes out ahead
Treat the two scores as a range rather than a contradiction. A fair reading is that the 85 is what Puppeteer earns from someone who buys into the show, and the 75 is closer to where it lands for someone who wants a plainer, tighter platformer. Both numbers count as a good game.
It's a PlayStation 3 exclusive from Japan Studio, released September 5, 2013, and that limits who can play it. If you have the console and like theatrical platformers, it's an easy recommendation, especially for a parent and child who can split the two characters between them. Solo players who find dual-stick control fiddly should expect something closer to the lower score.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Puppeteer (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q3891642 wikidata.org