Analysis · Rain World

Rain World builds a living food chain, then makes you fight its controls

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One critic's game of the year, another's near-collapse

Few games split critics this cleanly. PCGamesN's reviewer named Rain World one of the best games of 2017, crediting its "thrilling desperation" and arguing that learning from hundreds of deaths paid off. IGN looked at the same systems and argued that, stacked together, they leave the game at risk of "toppling" under its own weight.

Both critics are describing the same 2D survival platformer from Videocult. You guide a slugcat, part cat and part slug, through the ruins of an industrial civilization as it searches for its lost family. Nearly everything it meets wants to eat it.

The averages hide that split. Critic aggregates for the PC and console versions sit at 69/100 across 16 reviews. Another lists 67/100 from 67 reviews, with only 44% of critics recommending the game, and a third reaches 76/100 from 10. The critic average, computed from those aggregates, is 7.1 out of 10. Few individual reviews landed anywhere near that middle.

The creatures are the reason to care

Every creature in Rain World wanders, hunts and fights on its own schedule. Camouflaged carnivorous plants wait in the open. Vultures that give off gas circle overhead. Brightly colored lizards prowl the pipes, and scavengers armed with explosive spears stay friendly until provoked. None of them follow set paths, so no two trips through a room play out the same way.

This is where the praise concentrates. Rock, Paper, Shotgun treated each new species as a puzzle to read, which led to moments of real discovery. GameSpot listed tricks the systems allow:

  • carrying a glowing mouse as a lantern through a dark room
  • planting spears in walls to climb on
  • luring predators into fighting each other while the slugcat slips past

Nintendo World Report, reviewing in 2019, said the creature behavior deserved its "own level of praise" next to the fixed enemies of most platformers. Shacknews liked the pacing, with long quiet stretches broken by sudden run-ins, and admired a setting that doesn't revolve around the player.

Where the design turns on the player

The loop is strict. Each cycle, the slugcat forages enough food to hibernate, then reaches one of the scarce shelters before the rain floods everything and kills it. Shelters are the only checkpoints. Each death costs a karma level, and karma gates on the borders of the 12 regions won't open below a set level. A yellow karma flower protects that level, but only one at a time.

Critics' complaints stacked up on the same few points:

  • Throwing. Many reviewers blamed imprecise aim for deaths they didn't earn. Rock, Paper, Shotgun said instructions for it would read like a "bizarre legal document".
  • Checkpoints. The same outlet called them among the worst in modern platform games.
  • Karma gates. GameSpot called them arbitrary and "disrespectful" of the player's time.
  • Repetition. Rooms reshuffle their enemies after each death, so retreading them stays risky. IGN called forced backtracking "antithetical" in a game where exploring is the reward.

Polygon's reviewer lost hours of progress and described herself as "miserable". Game Informer understood that the suffering was intentional, but argued the controls, the lack of guidance and the unpredictable enemies ruined the effect.

Harshness as theme, and the players who stayed anyway

A minority of critics read the friction as the point. With time, PC Gamer's reviewer came to see the controls as "thematically appropriate" for a game about being powerless. Paste called Rain World a "beautiful, forward-thinking game" but compared its precision demands to Devil May Cry and said its puzzles hand over only "half of the pieces". The only help comes from holograms sent by a worm-like creature watching the slugcat, and those hints get rarer as the game goes on.

The other slugcats change the balance. The Monk faces less aggressive creatures and needs less food to hibernate, which makes it the clear starting point for anyone wary of the reviews above. The Hunter goes the other way: it eats only meat, needs more of it, has to take down larger prey, and can carry extra spears. A four-player arena and a sandbox for spawning creatures round out the package.

Players kept going after many critics gave up. An active fanbase and a large modding community made Rain World a cult hit. Downpour, a DLC built from community-created content, was well received and sold 182,000 units on Steam in the months around its release, according to journalist Simon Carless.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet