Rare Replay packs 30 games and hides its best history behind a stamp card
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A high-water mark with a joke at its own expense
Critics put Rare Replay near the top of its kind. Kotaku called it the best compilation since Valve's The Orange Box, and Polygon called it "an essential piece of gaming history". The sharpest complaint is aimed at the part many reviewers liked most. The archive footage and developer interviews sit behind stamps earned through in-game challenges. Kotaku's Stephen Totilo called the stamps the package's "sickest joke", since Rare is known for collectible-heavy games.
The praise and the complaint can both be true. The critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.7 out of 10, and 96% of 72 critics in the largest sample recommended it. Reviewers also liked the value and the low price. How much you get out of it depends on how much grinding you'll accept to reach the history.
Thirty games, and the Nintendo 64 era carries them
The collection covers Rare and its predecessor, Ultimate Play the Game, from the ZX Spectrum in 1983 to the Xbox 360 in 2008. It spans fighting games, first-person shooters, simulation, platformers, racing and skiing. Reviewers' favorites were Blast Corps, Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts, the Viva Piñata games and the Nintendo 64 titles, above all Banjo-Kazooie, Conker and Perfect Dark. Their least favorites were Perfect Dark Zero, Grabbed by the Ghoulies and the early Spectrum games, which critics felt had aged the worst. Ars Technica defended those Spectrum games as a look at a rougher, more experimental Rare.
The Nintendo 64 emulation pleased critics. It upgrades polygon rendering and frame rate, which Ars Technica said made up for "blurry" source material. The same review found that the multiplayer modes didn't get the frame rate boost. Ars Technica also backed Rare's choice to emulate the original Conker's Bad Fur Day rather than its censored Xbox remake. Early reviews called Jet Force Gemini unplayable without dual thumbstick controls, which were added later.
Modern help for games built to be hard
The core games are unedited, but the older ones get several additions:
- a rewind of up to ten seconds in pre-Nintendo 64 games
- saving at any point, plus an autosave when you quit
- an infinite lives cheat in some older games
- a fix for a game-breaking bug in Battletoads
- Snapshots, short timed challenges cut from the older games, some linked as playlists
Critics singled out the rewind, especially for the notoriously hard Battletoads. Ars Technica wished it worked in the Nintendo 64 games as well. Polygon found the Snapshots helped with learning basic mechanics but called them less accessible than NES Remix.
The weak spot is controls. Reviewers found the Spectrum controls hard to figure out. Ars Technica's reviewer said the package did a poor job explaining each game's controls and turned to YouTube videos and outside FAQs instead. Eurogamer and Ars Technica disagreed on whether the Spectrum emulator should reproduce the original hardware's graphical glitches.
The gaps in Rare's own story
Licensing kept out the games many critics rated as Rare's best: Donkey Kong Country, GoldenEye 007 and Diddy Kong Racing. Some critics regretted that, while others felt the package was fine without them. GoldenEye 007 was later given free to owners of the digital version in January 2023.
The bonus material has gaps too. Kotaku noted that it offers no straightforward history of the company and plays down Rare's former ties to Nintendo. Eurogamer's Dan Whitehead wondered why Mire Mare and other early games were left out. Founders Tim and Chris Stamper don't appear at all, an absence reviewers noticed. Ars Technica's Sam Machkovech saw the set as much a "memorial" as an anthology.
If you're here for the extras, expect to spend a lot of time. Ars Technica's reviewer was not even halfway through the stamp card after finishing the easiest achievements, which left the unreleased game footage especially hard to reach.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Rare Replay en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20538675 wikidata.org