Rise of Lyric trades Sonic's speed for brawling and buckles under its bugs
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Four heroes, one whip and a lot of easy fights
Most of the game is running, punching and switching between Sonic, Tails, Knuckles and Amy. Each one has a job. Sonic has his speed and homing attack, Tails flies and uses gadgets, Knuckles burrows and climbs walls, and Amy swings on poles with her hammer. You can't always choose freely, because not every character is available at every point.
All four carry the Enerbeam, a whip-like tool that handles a lot of the work. It lets you hang from speeding rails, strip shields off enemies and solve puzzles. Along the way you collect up to 100 rings and pick up scrap metal to upgrade your stats.
The fighting didn't win critics over. Reviewers called the combat "tedious" and the difficulty low. That's a bad pairing in a game that puts more weight on combat than earlier Sonic games did.
A Sonic game that mostly asks you to slow down
There are four kinds of stage:
- fast platforming stages in the style of the main series
- high-speed tracks where you dodge obstacles
- slower stages built around exploration
- boss battles
That mix leans away from what the series is known for. Big Red Button and IllFonic built it on CryEngine as an action-adventure game first. In the story, the four heroes try to stop Lyric, the last Ancient, from getting the Chaos Crystals, and Doctor Eggman, Metal Sonic and Shadow show up too. The variety looks good on paper. The trouble is that the slower stages lean on the combat critics found dull.
The bugs did more damage than the design
Technical problems drove most of the criticism. Don Saas of GameSpot said sound effects failed to play most of the time, that he could clip through the environments, and that the game once crashed his Wii U. The Independent noted frame drops and called the whole game rushed and unpolished.
IGN was the mildest major critic, and even its defense isn't much of a recommendation:
IGN called it "thoroughly disappointing and unpolished" but said it isn't broken or unplayable.
One more detail matters. Sega didn't send reviewers advance copies of Rise of Lyric, so reviews could only start once it was already on sale.
Good animation, tired dialogue and unfinished outdoors
The presentation got a little credit. IGN liked the character animation, then said nearly every other part of the presentation dragged the game down, especially the same quotes repeating for basic actions. Tim Turi of Game Informer complained that the characters "won't shut up" about loving rings, and that Eggman keeps reaching for dated meme catchphrases.
Destructoid split the art in two. It said the characters and indoor areas looked good, while the outdoor areas looked half-finished. Common Sense Media gave it one out of five and called it a "sub-par Sonic game".
Why the multiplayer can't save it
The best thing it offers is time with other people. There's local two-player co-op, plus minigames for up to four players at once, and some critics praised those minigames. That's a small bright spot in a game that's otherwise single-player and story-led.
Critics' overall verdict was harsh. The game holds a Metacritic score of 32/100 and a GameRankings score of 33.15%, the lowest for any Sonic game on either site. The critic average, worked out from those critic scores, is 3.1 out of 10. David Jenkins of GameCentral named it the worst game of 2014. Game Informer also put it among the year's worst, and Nintendo Life called it the worst Sonic game in the series' history. Sega reported that the two Sonic Boom games had sold a combined 620,000 copies as of March 31, 2015, which put them among the lowest-selling games in the franchise.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q18536880 wikidata.org