Analysis · Saints Row

Saints Row copied the open-world crime formula and fixed what annoyed people

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A familiar crime sandbox with the friction filed down

Nearly every critic compared Saints Row to the Grand Theft Auto series, and what they disagreed about was whether that mattered. Some thought it improved on Grand Theft Auto's gameplay. Others faulted it for a lack of originality. Steven Embling of play.tm said it wouldn't win "awards for originality" but still called its graphics and sound "impressive."

The case for it comes from Scott Sharkey at 1UP.com. He noted that it dropped two old annoyances: load times between city sections and combat that leaned on auto-aim. Ryan McCaffrey of GamesRadar+ called it a worthy entry in a genre beholden to Grand Theft Auto, and he praised its graphics and its use of the Havok engine.

So the game's core idea is the familiar formula with fewer rough edges. Every other part of the game is best judged by whether it keeps that promise or breaks it.

Respect is the toll on every story mission

The story is split into three linear arcs, one for each rival gang the 3rd Street Saints set out to wipe out. You can play the arcs side by side or one at a time. That freedom is a real change from a single fixed plot line.

The catch is the Respect meter. Before you can start a mission, you have to fill a bar of Respect, and you earn Respect by playing activities. These are minigames spread across the city that get harder as you go. This is where critics split most clearly:

  • McCaffrey at GamesRadar+ said the Respect system disrupted the story's momentum.
  • Will Tuttle at GameSpy granted that not every player would like being gated, but said the activities "offer some of the game's most memorable sequences."

The design softens the blow in other places. A failed mission can be retried right away without losing any Respect, and cinemas around the city let you replay finished missions as often as you like. Those are the same kind of fixes Sharkey praised, but the Respect gate works against them. It adds back the padding the rest of the design removes.

The satire is where the imitation shows

Where the game copies Grand Theft Auto's attitude without its touch, critics were harsh. Sharkey called its attempts at urban gang culture and satire "so hackneyed" that they embarrassed the whole game. The Sydney Morning Herald said it lacked Grand Theft Auto's subtlety and sense of mischief, and that much of its humor fell flat. It still gave the game four stars out of five.

Not everyone minded. The Times gave it five stars and warned that it would "offend and entertain in equal measure." It's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18, and The Times was blunt that it is not for children.

Critics liked how it played more than how it talked. The fixes to the formula worked, and the jokes mostly didn't.

Stilwater and the character you build

The city of Stilwater is modeled on Baltimore, Detroit and Chicago. You can move through it on foot, by swimming or by car, with a third-person camera you can rotate freely. You build your character at the start, choosing ethnicity, fitness, face and hairstyle. You can change all of it later at a plastic surgeon, and you can add more through clothing stores, tattoo parlors, barbers and jewelers.

Cars get the same treatment. Chop shops tune vehicles, a personal garage stores them, and a car that's been destroyed or lost can be redeemed for a cash fee. Losing a car costs you money instead of making you start over, which fits the game's habit of cutting out frustration. The Detroit Free Press gave it four stars and called it the deepest of the freewheeling street shooters so far, with "missions and activities galore."

How the record scores it

Metacritic counted 74 reviews of the Xbox 360 version and landed at 81/100. A second aggregate of 19 reviews came in lower at 67/100. That gap matches the split over originality. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.4 out of 10.

The game also got recognition beyond reviews. GameSpot named it "Most Surprisingly Good Game of 2006." The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for Action/Adventure Game of the Year, for its story and character development, and for Tia Carrere's performance as Lin. It sold over 2 million copies and joined the Xbox 360 Platinum Hits line.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet