Sekiro trades health bars for posture and demands near-perfect timing
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics called the combat beautiful, and some called it infuriating
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice drew some of the warmest praise FromSoftware has had for its swordplay, along with some of the bluntest complaints about how hard it is. At PC Gamer, Tom Senior called the combat "beautiful" and the difficulty "brutal" but "spectacular." At The Spinoff, Don Rowe called it "infuriating" and wrote about not having fun after six hours. Both reactions come from the same design: a game built around exact timing that won't bend for players who can't find it.
Most critics landed with Senior. OpenCritic found that 96% of critics recommend the game. Metacritic lists "universal acclaim" for the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions and "generally favorable reviews" for Windows. The game also won Game of the Year at the Game Awards 2019. The critic average, computed from the critic aggregates, is 9.0.
Fights are won by breaking posture, not draining health
Your katana doesn't whittle down a health bar. It wears down an enemy's posture. You deflect incoming strikes and keep up the pressure until their balance breaks, and then one deathblow ends the fight. Senior described it as overwhelming the posture bar "with strikes and perfect parries" until an opening appears. He argued that the system packs the payoff of beating a great boss into a single split second.
Critics read this as a real break from FromSoftware's earlier games. Destructoid's Chris Carter likened open combat to "a waltz" and said it gives players more choices than Dark Souls or Bloodborne. IGN's Brandin Tyrell found the timing familiar but the feel "refreshing and new." GameSpot's Tamoor Hussain wrote that it "rewrites the rules of engagement."
Two systems take some of the edge off:
- Stealth. If you get within range undetected, you can kill most enemies outright or badly wound them. Reviewers liked the freedom this gave without it turning into frustration.
- Resurrection. With resurrection power, which comes back as you defeat enemies, you revive on the spot instead of back at a checkpoint. Carter called it "genius."
The trade-off is less role-playing depth. There's no character creation and no spreading points across stats. Progress comes from gear upgrades, prosthetic arm abilities, a skill tree and limited ability customization.
A grappling hook pulls the levels upward
A grappling hook and a dedicated jump button let these levels climb in a way the older Soulsborne games never did. Tyrell wrote that the hook "sends ripples throughout the gameplay." Carter noted that it made exploration more vertical and, in places, more demanding.
The world is built from large but separate zones rather than one connected map. Senior still praised the secrets hidden just off the main path, reached by swinging between tree branches and rooftops. Hussain described buildings placed with roofs almost touching so you can leap between them and scout every angle. He also liked the branching paths that lead into the unknown and then out somewhere familiar.
No multiplayer, but a real pause button
Sekiro is single-player only, and critics were split on that. Several welcomed what it allowed: a full pause button. Tyrell missed the notes other players leave to warn of threats or point to secrets, and the sense that an invading player could be close behind. He also argued that the deflect-and-block swordplay would have suited player-versus-player duels, and called their absence a waste.
The difficulty decides who this is for
Hussain wrote that the game "punishes you for missteps" and suits a "slightly masochistic" taste, but called victory "gratifying." Tyrell judged it somewhat easier than its predecessors, though with a steep climb to mastery. Not everyone made that climb. Within days of launch, modders released mods that made the game easier by changing the character's speed relative to the game. PC Gamer's James Davenport said the final boss was too hard to beat without one.
The game offers no way around its timing except practice. Rowe's six hours without fun is the warning sign to weigh.
Plenty of players took the challenge on anyway. Sekiro drew over 108,000 concurrent players on Steam on release day and had sold over 10 million units as of September 2023.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q54906424 wikidata.org