Analysis · Skul: The Hero Slayer

Skul's head-swapping combat won critics over, even where its story didn't

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed on the fighting and split on the music

The clearest split among reviewers was over the sound. Alex Orona of Nintendo World Report liked the music. Ben Kuchera of Polygon called it repetitive and counted it as a weakness. That one disagreement says a lot about the game, because both critics agreed on nearly everything that happens while you play.

Orona praised the fast-paced combat. Kuchera enjoyed the enemy behavior and how well the fights are put together, and said that outweighed the complaints. Travis Northrup of IGN singled out how many different playstyles the skulls make possible. Across 40 counted reviews, aggregate scores sit at 82/100, and the critic average computed from those critic numbers is 8.2.

So the critics weren't really arguing about whether Skul is good. They were arguing about how well it holds up after many runs. A track that sounds lively on the first run can wear thin many runs later, and that kind of wear is the thread that runs through every complaint below.

The skull swap is the whole pitch

Skul: The Hero Slayer is a 2D side-scrolling action platformer with roguelike structure. You play Skul, a skeleton soldier in the Demon King's army, pushing through randomly generated levels to rescue the castle's residents from the heroes who captured them.

His basic kit is small. He slashes with a bone, dodges, and throws his own skull, either to hit enemies or to teleport to wherever it lands. The depth comes from the heads he finds along the way:

  • Each skull you pick up replaces his own and gives him a new set of combat abilities.
  • He can carry two at once and switch between them mid-fight.
  • After each level you choose between two doors, which can lead to a new skull, gold, a shop or a sanctuary where gold buys hit points or items.

That two-skull pairing drives the build-making in each run, and it's what Northrup was pointing to in praising the variety. IGN compared the game to Dead Cells and to The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask, which suggests the outlet saw both tight action and identity-swapping as central.

Where the runs start to repeat

Levels are procedurally generated, but the structure is fixed: a boss after every three stages. Northrup criticized those bosses as repetitive. In a game built on replaying, that's a real cost, because you'll face the same gatekeepers again and again before you see the next stretch.

Polygon's complaint about the music lands in the same place. Neither problem matters much early on. Both matter more the longer you stay with it, and staying with it is the point of a roguelite.

The story gives you little reason to care

On the story, the critics more or less agreed. Orona found it sparse and simplistic. Kuchera described it as poorly translated. Nobody in the reception put the plot forward as a reason to play.

Play it for the next skull, not the next scene.

The premise is a nice inversion: you're the demon army's lowest grunt, and the heroes are the invaders. But the writing doesn't do much with it. Go in expecting a premise, not a narrative.

Who the disagreement points to

Taken together, the reviews describe a game for players who get their fun from mechanics. If finding a strong pair of skulls, learning enemy patterns and taking one more run is enough to keep you going, the weaknesses critics named are easy to live with. If you need bosses that keep surprising you or a story that pays off, those same weaknesses show up early and stay.

It's also easy to pick up on whatever you own. It launched on Windows, macOS and Linux on January 21, 2021, reached Switch, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One in October 2021, and came to Android and iOS on June 4, 2024. It's rated Teen and PEGI 12, and it's single-player only.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet