Skyrim fixed Oblivion's world and classes but kept its stiff melee
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fifth entry moved the series north
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is the fifth main game in The Elder Scrolls series and the follow-up to The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (2006). Bethesda Game Studios built it on the Creation Engine, and it launched on November 11, 2011 for Windows, PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360. Later releases added PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and Series S.
The biggest change is the setting. Oblivion was set in the Imperial Province of Cyrodiil. For Skyrim the team picked a rugged, mostly sub-arctic land modeled on Scandinavia, which game director Todd Howard saw as more distinctive. Critics responded strongly. Four editors at Famitsu gave it a combined 40/40, the first Western-developed game to earn that, and the critic average, computed from the critic aggregates, is 9.3 out of 10.
Dropping classes was the right call
Earlier games in the series asked players to choose a class at the start. Skyrim drops that. After choosing a sex and one of 10 races, players improve 18 skills, split evenly across combat, magic and stealth, simply by using them. Forging a dagger raises Smithing, and landing arrows raises Archery. Enough skill gains lead to a character level, which raises health, magicka or stamina and grants a perk point.
Reviewers liked the change almost without exception. Charles Onyett of IGN and Billy Shibley of Inside Gaming both said it let players experiment instead of committing to a build too early. John Bedford of Eurogamer pointed out that the system still rewards players who want to specialize. Kevin VanOrd of GameSpot said the perks shape themselves around the way each player plays while leaving room to adjust them. Bedford also praised the interface's "elegant design" over Oblivion's busier menus.
Classes are gone, so what a character becomes depends on what the player actually does.
A world that looks handmade
Critics praised the world even more than the systems. Jason Schreier of Wired found Cyrodiil generic by comparison. Edge called the old province a "patchwork" of terrains and preferred Skyrim's more consistent design. Shibley singled out the absence of copy-and-paste level design, a habit of earlier Bethesda games.
Dungeons were a known weak point in Oblivion, and Andrew Reiner of Game Informer said Skyrim's were largely unique. He also praised a small fix that saves time: most dungeons end with a shortcut out of the last room, so players no longer walk all the way back to the entrance. Tom Francis of PC Gamer described a map so full of caves, shacks, standing stones and haunted forts that it's hard to walk for a minute without getting sidetracked.
Combat gained one well-liked feature, which was wielding a weapon or spell in each hand. PC PowerPlay said it changes the tactics of every fight, and Shibley liked combining a different spell in each hand.
What it carried over from Oblivion
Some old problems came along too. Justin McElroy of Joystiq said fights are weighed down by the same "clunky melee" Oblivion had. Onyett called the swordplay "floaty", and Francis said enemies barely react when hit. Melee is a common way to play, so this flaw affects more players than any other.
The dragons were a highlight at first, but several critics found them predictable. Francis described a simple routine: ignore them until they land, then attack from a distance. Reiner thought they were too easy for low-level characters. Edge noted the opposite problem for archers and mages, who struggle to hit a dragon while it's flying.
Critics were split on the main quest. Reiner called it Bethesda's best story so far. Steve Butts of The Escapist and Francis objected that most of it is delivered through conversations and journal entries rather than through what the player does.
Then there are the bugs. Many reviewers ran into glitches, and some were serious enough to break the game. Nick Cowen of The Guardian had to reload older saves, though he saw the glitches as the price of the game's ambition. Edge opened its review by criticizing the lack of polish before listing everything that makes up for it.
Save often, and keep more than one save file. Critics agreed the bugs were worth putting up with, but losing progress to one is still frustrating.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q323862 wikidata.org