Sonic's only RPG lives or dies on how much you like tapping in rhythm
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fights split critics down the middle
Critics disagreed most about the combat in Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood. Ryan Scott of 1Up.com called the battle system a joy. Nintendo Power found that it became a "major annoyance" in the second half of the game, though it still thought the game was worth sticking with. Both were describing the same system. Battles are turn-based, and special attacks, called POW Moves, are performed by tapping the stylus in rhythm.
Reviewers compared the combat to Elite Beat Agents (2006), and that comparison explains the split. If you like timed tapping, each special attack is a small rhythm test. If you don't, the game asks for it again and again, and by the later chapters the repetition wears. POW Moves spend POW Points, which work like magic points in other RPGs. Some group attacks need specific characters in the party. The Blue Bomber, for example, needs both Sonic and Tails.
Easy enough that critics pointed it at kids
Critics agreed more often than they disagreed, and difficulty was the clearest example. Several said they were surprised by how simple and forgiving the game is. GamePro and PALGN both said it would suit younger players, and Emily Balistrieri called it a "fairly easy and light RPG".
The Everyone and PEGI 7 ratings fit that view. The systems ask little of the player:
- Each fight drops loot, from healing items to equipment, and each character has three equipment slots.
- Experience raises up to two of four attributes per character: speed, attack, defense and luck.
- Chao are collectible helpers. Each has its own ability that boosts a team member's stats, and they live in the Chao Garden.
You explore with the stylus by tapping where you want a character to go, and buttons handle set pieces like vertical loops. Sometimes a specific character has to lead so the party can fly, climb or jump a gap. Some puzzles split the party up to press switches. Swapping Chao over the DS's wireless connection is the only shared feature, and critics called the lack of other multiplayer options a disappointment.
A thin story that pays off late
The plot starts with Knuckles' kidnapping and the missing Chaos Emeralds after Doctor Eggman's defeat. It then moves across two dimensions as the cast meets a new ally, Shade the Echidna, and tries to stop an invasion led by Ix, leader of the Nocturnus. Critics found the chapter-based story lightweight and cartoony compared with other RPGs, and said the play matters more than the plot.
Reviewers also agreed that the story gets more ambitious and more interesting in the second half. Matthew Castle of Computer and Video Games wrote that only later does BioWare start using its "universe-building weight". Brian Fore of Game Informer found the characters well written and likeable.
The second half is where the writing improves, and it's also where Nintendo Power lost patience with the combat.
A player who enjoys the tapping gets the better story as a reward. A player who doesn't has to push through the most repetitive fights to reach it.
Looks that divided critics, sound that didn't
The visuals got a second, smaller split. Eurogamer called the game "undeniably nice-looking", and IGN agreed, praising its models and environments. GamePro disagreed and said the in-game graphics fall short of the sharp cut-scenes. On sound, the critics lined up: IGN noted poor audio quality, and GamePro called the soundtrack and sound effects "primitive".
It's still the only RPG in the Sonic the Hedgehog series, and it has been largely cut off from the rest of it. Former Archie Comics head writer Ken Penders sued Sega and Electronic Arts, claiming the Nocturnus were drawn from his echidna characters. The case was dismissed. Bobby Schroeder of Intelligencer speculated that the game's content has rarely reappeared since because of the dispute. The Sonic the Hedgehog Encyclo-speed-ia (2021) declared the game non-canon. If you want to see this side of Sonic, this is the only game that has it.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q546745 wikidata.org