Analysis · Sons of the Forest

Sons of the Forest is a bigger, scarier island built for friends

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for survival fans who want company

Sons of the Forest is for players who enjoyed The Forest and wanted more of it: more island, more help and more people to share the fear with. Endnight Games made it and Newnight published it. You play someone sent to a mysterious island to find a missing CEO and his family. The island is full of cannibalistic monsters, and an ancient secret is buried deep underground.

The loop is classic survival. You gather materials, build weapons and shelters, and try to stay alive. Up to eight players can work together in co-op, and solo play is an option too. What you do along the way decides which of several endings you get.

Where it delivers: a huge map and two odd allies

The island is four times bigger than the map in The Forest, and critics noticed. In its early access review, IGN said the sequel does everything its predecessor did well "a little bit better," pointing to the larger map, sharper graphics and improved AI. GamingBolt called it "extremely scary" and packed with content.

The companions are what set this game apart from its predecessor:

  • Kelvin is deaf-mute, so you give him orders written on paper. He can collect crafting resources or set up fires, which takes some of the grind off your hands.
  • Virginia has three legs and three arms. She's skittish at first, but you can win her trust and then arm her to fight beside you.

There's also 3D printing, one of several new systems layered on top of the familiar building. For Rock Paper Shotgun, Matt Cox called the setting the game's strongest point. In her review of the 1.0 release, IGN's Leana Hafer praised the story and the sense of tension and said the game improved on The Forest "in just about every way."

Where it falls short: fighting and forced progress

The same Rock Paper Shotgun review that praised the island found the combat lacking. Cox also felt that quests required to move the plot forward limited the sense of progression. That matters in a game built on freedom: if you came for open-ended survival, being steered by story beats can feel like a leash.

The early access version had real problems. IGN flagged poor performance and an unfinished story at that stage. Hafer's 1.0 review says the full release runs better, so the early complaints describe an older build. The game is available only on Microsoft Windows.

The finished game and its numbers

Sons of the Forest entered early access on February 23, 2023, and reached full release on February 22, 2024. Its launch was huge. It passed Starfield as the most wishlisted game on Steam, sold over 2 million copies within 24 hours, hit more than 250,000 concurrent players on day one and became the best-selling game on Steam at the time.

Critics were warmer than lukewarm but stopped short of rapturous. Metacritic lists its reviews as "generally favorable." The aggregates in the record, both dated March 14, 2024 and drawn from 12 reviews, come to 78/100 and 86%. The critic average of 7.8 is calculated from those critic aggregates, not from a review of our own.

The short version from critics: a better Forest in nearly every way, with combat as the part that never quite catches up.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet