Analysis · Spiritfarer

Spiritfarer turns saying goodbye into a daily routine of cooking and building

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Most of your time goes into feeding and housing the dead

In Spiritfarer you play as Stella, a ferrywoman for the dead who travels with her cat, Daffodil. A typical stretch of play is caretaking. You cook meals for the spirits on your boat, take on their errands and gather materials so you can build more of the ship.

Those materials go into kitchens, gardens and other rooms that help your passengers feel at home. Each new section snaps onto a square grid and can be stacked on top of others. As you upgrade the ship's capacity, you get more room to build. Vendors sell seeds for the gardens and ingredients for recipes, and some passengers ask for particular dishes. That gives the cooking a goal beyond keeping everyone fed.

The spirits also bring mini-games that pay out in materials and money, and each one is tied to who that character is. Alice, a grandmother character, has you gather a creature's offspring alongside her. IGN's Tom Marks summed up the mix as part Animal Crossing and part action platformer, which is a fair shorthand for a game that asks you to tend things as often as jump between them.

Every friendship ends at the Everdoor

Each spirit's quests reveal more of their past, and each storyline ends the same way: you take them to the Everdoor, the gate to the afterlife, and they leave the boat for good. You don't decide when a story is over. The game makes the parting happen.

Critics pointed to that as the point of the whole thing. Marks wrote that being made to let beloved characters go hit hard, and he called the cast charming, with stories he described as "somber, touching." He also noted that some characters matter more than others, so the departures don't all carry the same weight.

PC Gamer's Rachel Watts said the game handles death and compassion with "masterful balance."

Watts had one real complaint. The game deliberately leaves the afterlife and its residents vague, and she felt that "purposeful vagueness" made it harder to tell what some characters actually want. If you need clear rules for a fantasy world, expect some gaps.

Where the routine wears thin

The biggest criticism from reviewers is about pacing, not story. Marks found the backtracking tiresome and the overall formula predictable over time. He also warned that the everyday jobs get "repetitive fast" if you try to be efficient about them.

That warning is useful. Spiritfarer gives you a lot of small tasks, and treating them like a checklist works against it. USgamer's Eric Van Allen, who rated it 4/5, said the game is "best enjoyed in small pieces." Short sessions keep the chores from stacking up and leave room for the characters.

  • Play in short sessions: an evening with one or two errands fits the game better than a marathon.
  • Don't over-plan the ship: critics say the grind shows most when you chase perfect efficiency.
  • Expect repeat trips: backtracking is part of the structure, not a rare annoyance.

Bright to look at, with writing that won awards attention

Even with death at its center, critics found the game colorful and uplifting. Marks called it "feel-good," and Watts called it a "wholesome life-sim." Van Allen described the writing as "warm, funny and charming," so the jokes are there to soften the losses, not to cover them up.

Awards bodies agreed. Spiritfarer was nominated for Games For Impact and Best Indie Game at The Game Awards 2020, was a finalist for both the Nebula Award for Best Game Writing and the Hugo Award for Best Video Game, and received a nomination for Outstanding Achievement in Animation at the 24th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards. Critic aggregates sit between 80 and 90 out of 100 across the versions reviewed. Thunder Lotus Games said it had sold one million copies by December 2021.

It came out on August 18, 2020, and runs on Windows, macOS, Linux, PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch. It's rated Teen and PEGI 12, which suits a story about grief told gently, not graphically.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet