Starfield's 1,000 planets split critics more than its story did
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fight was over getting from planet to planet
Critics disagreed most about space travel. PC Gamer said the game "fails to feel like a grand adventure" and faulted how much travel relies on loading screens and fast travel between planets. Digital Trends wanted more depth from space travel and found the 1,000 planets repetitive. Destructoid read the same sandbox the other way and praised how unpredictable it is and how much there is to find.
Both sides are describing the same design. You can land on more than 1,000 planets plus moons and space stations. Most of the terrain on those planets is procedurally generated from each system's star and atmosphere. Handcrafted locations sit around points of interest. You scan a planet for iron or lithium before landing, then extract it to feed crafting and outposts.
So the split is really about expectations. If you see travel as menus that move you between pockets of content, the scale pays off. If you wanted flying between stars to be the adventure, the critics who were disappointed are describing your experience. Todd Howard later acknowledged complaints that the game lacked "organic exploration" and said that kind of exploring is harder in a game built like this one.
Skip ahead to the side quests
The story divided critics too, but there was a pattern in the split. IGN liked the worldbuilding and the number of interesting companions, and said the side quests gave real room to role-play. Digital Trends found the characters "one-note" but still praised the variety of side quests. TechRadar called the main story "soulless".
Read those together and the side quests are the safe bet. Even the critics who were cool on the main plot singled them out. The main thread, where you join a group of explorers hunting artifacts across 50 light-years around the Sol System, has fewer defenders.
The companions matter more than in a typical shooter. Crew members fight beside you, carry gear, speak for you in confrontations and react to your choices. Some can be romanced. You can also post them at outposts you build.
What critics agreed on
- The music. Inon Zur's score got steady praise. Destructoid said its themes suit the setting, and Shacknews called it "phenomenal".
- The build options. Your background sets three starting skills. Traits can help or hurt; Introvert, for example, gives more endurance alone and less with a companion. Progress runs through five skill trees: Physical, Social, Combat, Science and Tech.
- Combat that changes with the setting. Gravity depends on each planet's mass, which affects jumps, boost pack height and fall damage. Contraband like the time-slowing drug Aurora, legal only in the city of Neon, can get you fined, jailed or attacked if you're caught smuggling it.
- A cleaner launch than usual. Several reviewers noted fewer bugs than in earlier Bethesda games. GamesRadar+'s Leon Hurley called it the studio's best work since The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion.
Players were harder on it than critics
Player reception was much colder. As of January 2024, the Windows version had a "mixed" rating from players on Steam, and IGN's Wesley Yin-Poole noted it was the lowest-rated Bethesda game ever on that platform. Players complained about loading screens, called it boring or generic, and reported bugs that were frequent and sometimes serious. Mods fixed some of them before official patches did. The first expansion, Shattered Space, had a "mostly negative" Steam rating as of January 2025. One smaller critic aggregate came in at 64/100, well below the 83 to 85 range of the larger ones.
Lead systems designer Kurt Kuhlmann later said the game "didn't fully cohere" and fell short of its original vision.
That comment explains the gap. Each system on its own drew praise. The complaints came from how the systems connect: travel broken up by loading screens, generated planets between the handcrafted places, and a main story weaker than its side quests. If you play for the parts, you'll likely agree with the critics. If you need the whole thing to feel connected, you'll probably side with the players.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Starfield (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q55286432 wikidata.org