Super Mario RPG turns every turn-based hit into a timing test
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every attack asks for a well-timed button press
Fights start the old-fashioned way. Each turn you pick from a menu: attack, defend, run, use an item or cast magic. The twist is the action command. A timed button press during an attack, a special move, a block or an item boosts its effect. A well-timed press makes a basic hit land harder or takes the sting out of an enemy blow, so even routine fights ask you to pay attention.
You also choose who fights. The party starts with Mario alone and grows to five, with Mario plus two others in each battle. You can swap the other two while exploring. Each character has their own moves:
- Princess Peach mostly heals.
- Geno and Bowser deal heavy damage.
- Mario is always in the lineup.
There are no random encounters. Enemies walk around in plain sight, and a fight starts only when Mario touches one. If you're low on health or short on time, you can walk around them.
Between fights, it plays like a Mario platformer
Outside battle, the game is an isometric 3D platformer. You jump, explore and punch floating question blocks from below, as in the main Mario series. The structure borrows from Square's other role-playing games, the Final Fantasy series among them: a world to explore, a party to build and turn-based fights.
Critics split on the battle system. RPGamer's Derek Cavin wrote that most of its mechanics "aren't very original." A Next Generation reviewer saw it the other way: the parts that break from the usual formula are the parts that make it feel like Mario. That reviewer also found it hard enough for seasoned players and simple enough for newcomers. GamePro's Scary Larry agreed, calling it "genuinely tough" while still friendly to beginners.
The timed button press is the hook. If a menu-driven fight has ever felt like paperwork to you, this is the version that gives your hands a job.
The art and music did most of the winning
Nearly every critic praised how the game looks. Most of that praise is for the original 1996 Super NES game. Electronic Gaming Monthly called its graphics "the best seen on the Super NES," and Allgame's Skyler Miller called them the "high watermark" for 3D on a 16-bit system. Nintendo Power argued that the 3D look helped the game reach a wider audience than most traditional role-playing games.
The sound got the same kind of praise. Miller called the music "quite extraordinary" and said each piece fits its setting. IGN's Lucas Thomas called the soundtrack "spectacular" and pointed to the game's humor, story and mini-games, which break up long stretches of adventuring. Humor is the most consistent theme in the reviews: even critics with complaints liked the jokes.
The Switch release kept that goodwill. As of January 20, 2024, it held 84/100 across 115 critic reviews, and 92% of 114 reviews were positive.
A strong first run, a thin second one
There's more to do than the main path. Scary Larry pointed to the sidequests and extras, including Toadofsky's music levels, as replay value. Miller saw it differently. He found the battle music "monotonous" after many fights and said a second run holds no real surprises.
The story gets mixed notes. Cavin criticized the "lack of a unified storyline," and 1UP.com found the characters too childish for older players. Next Generation argued that the characters and the well-built world hold the whole game together. If you want a deep, connected plot, expect less of one here. If you want a cast with personality, critics say it delivers.
Its place on later best-of lists is the best sign of how well it has aged. Official Nintendo Magazine ranked it 34th among the greatest Nintendo games in 2009, Complex put it 8th among Super Nintendo games in 2018, and Time Extension named it one of the best JRPGs of all time in 2023.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Super Mario RPG (2023 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q119822934 wikidata.org