Analysis · The Last Guardian

The Last Guardian bets everything on a giant creature that won't always obey

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Ueda's third game keeps the old formula and adds a partner with a will of its own

The Last Guardian follows Ico (2001) and Shadow of the Colossus (2005), and it plays like a close relative of both. It's a third-person mix of action-adventure and puzzle solving. An unnamed boy sits at the center, and the game drops him into the ruins of an ancient civilization with almost no explanation. Japan Studio and genDESIGN released it on December 6, 2016, as a PlayStation 4 exclusive from Sony Interactive Entertainment.

The big change is Trico, a giant creature that's half bird, half mammal. In Ico you led a companion by the hand. Here the companion is many times your size and doesn't always listen. Nearly every success and every complaint in the game's reviews comes back to that one design choice.

The boy climbs, Trico carries

The split of work is simple. Each character opens the way for the other:

  • The boy climbs structures, carries barrels, pulls levers, and clears obstacles that stop Trico, such as gates and the glass eyes that frighten it.
  • Trico reaches ledges the boy can't and fights off the guards who try to carry him away.
  • Caretaking is part of the loop. The boy feeds Trico barrels when it's hungry, pets it to calm it after a fight and pulls out spears that enemies throw into it.

At first the player has little control over Trico. Over time the boy learns to direct it toward a ledge or in a certain direction, but the game also lets Trico wander, and new areas can turn up that way. Later, a reflective mirror lets the boy call lightning from Trico's tail to break certain objects. Falling too far or getting captured sends you back to the last checkpoint. Replays add costumes based on earlier Ueda games.

Critics loved Trico for the same reason some of them fought it

Most reviewers counted the environment and the story among the game's strongest parts, but Trico got most of the attention. Tom Senior of GamesRadar called it "the greatest AI companion in games" and pointed to the small visual and audio cues that give it character. At The Guardian, Simon Parkin read Trico, scared and imprisoned at the start, as the center of a story about "rehabilitation through kindness." GameSpot's Pete Brown found that Trico's stubborn streak added personality and built sympathy for both characters. Destructoid's Chris Carter called their behavior "emotive" in a way few developers would try.

The same realism that makes Trico feel alive also makes it slow to obey.

That was the other half of the reception. Marty Sliva of IGN found puzzles with Trico frustrating, especially indoors, where cramped rooms and the creature's size left him fighting the camera. He still praised the attachment to the characters. James Kozanitis of Game Revolution noticed Trico sometimes carrying on through an area without any input, which made giving it commands feel "ineffective and unnecessary."

The long development shows on a standard PlayStation 4

The technical record is less kind. Eurogamer's Digital Foundry found rendering problems and framerate drops on the original PlayStation 4, while the PlayStation 4 Pro held a stable framerate at 1080p. Polygon's Philip Kollar tied the rough edges to a development that ran across several generations of Sony consoles: some scenes make good use of the hardware, while the framerate and controls show the game's age.

Sam Byford of The Verge made the sharpest comparison. Shadow of the Colossus dropped frames too, but it was pushing the PlayStation 2 to its limits. On PlayStation 4 the same problem was harder to excuse, and he likened the result to "a PS3 game" that only shipped once newer hardware could carry it. If you have a PlayStation 4 Pro, play it there.

None of this kept it off year-end lists. The New Yorker, Engadget, GameSpot, VG247 and Polygon all named it among the year's best, and a 2023 GQ poll of games journalists ranked it the 88th best video game of all time. Its critic average of 8.1 is computed from those critic aggregates.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet