The Long Dark turns cold and hunger into the whole fight
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Beautiful to look at, and too hungry early on
The strongest praise critics gave The Long Dark was for how it looks and feels. At PC Gamer, Andy Kelly praised its art style, sound design and lighting, and argued that its focus on atmosphere set it apart in a crowded genre. Wired's Matt Peckham called it a "troubling yet beautiful gem," and IGN's Lucy O'Brien credited Hinterland with making the world itself a beautiful place to explore.
The sharpest criticism came from GameSpot. In an early access review, Nick Capozzoli complained that the game used up food and tools at an unrealistic rate: a survivor needed too many energy bars to get through a day, and a crowbar lost half its condition after prying open a couple of lockers. Instead of rationing like a real survivalist, he felt like an "insatiable force" stripping each area bare.
Both points come back to the same thing. The Long Dark asks you to believe in its wilderness, so the mood carries it and any crack in the realism stands out. The praise was about what the game is. Most of the complaints were about how it was tuned during early access, and Hinterland kept reworking it after that.
Survival mode is the main event
Survival mode is an open world with one goal: stay alive as long as you can. You manage body temperature, calories, hunger and fatigue, avoid dangerous wildlife, and treat illness and injuries such as frostbite or broken ribs. Fire keeps you warm and cooks your food. The full day and night cycle matters because nights are much colder.
At first, death ended every run. The Tales from the Far Territory DLC added Cheat Death, which lets you come back up to 3 times per save in exchange for a harder game. On misery, the hardest of the five difficulty levels, permadeath still applies.
- Pilgrim, voyageur, stalker, interloper and misery change the resources you can find, along with the wildlife and weather.
- Custom difficulty settings let you set the challenge yourself.
- The map spans 12 main regions, from Mystery Lake to Blackrock Mountain, joined by smaller transition regions. The DLC adds four more regions.
Map size was an early complaint. Leif Johnson at PC Gamer and Capozzoli both found the first map too small, and Johnson noted that it rewarded memorizing routes. Hinterland doubled the playable area that October and expanded it to 25 km2 by February 2015. John Walker at Rock, Paper, Shotgun found the game "impressively full of things to do," though he felt that time passed too quickly for the realism the rest of the game aims for.
Wintermute ran from 2017 to 2026 before it was finished
Story mode, called Wintermute, is an episodic adventure with survival systems but no permadeath. It switches between bush pilot Will Mackenzie and Dr. Astrid Greenwood, who are trying to find each other after crash-landing in the Canadian wilderness following a geomagnetic storm. Each episode limits you to certain regions.
Its release timeline tells you most of what you need to know:
- August 1, 2017: Episodes 1 and 2, Do Not Go Gentle and Luminance Fugue, launch together.
- December 2018: a new version of those two episodes arrives after player complaints, with changes to gameplay, presentation and mission structure.
- October 22, 2019: Episode 3, Crossroads Elegy.
- October 6, 2021: Episode 4, Fury, Then Silence.
- March 30, 2026: Episode 5, The Light at the End of All Things.
Rebuilding the first two episodes was an admission that the launch version fell short. The upside of the long wait is that the five-part story is now complete, so a new player won't be left on a cliffhanger. The writing also won a Webby Award for Best Writing in 2018, and the game won in the Strategy/Simulation category the same year.
Critic aggregates run from 69% to 84/100, and players go higher
Most critic aggregates land at 74/100 or 77/100. One counted 11 reviews for each platform and gave every version 74/100, from Nintendo Switch to PlayStation 5 and Windows. Another, based on 7 reviews, sits higher at 84/100. A third showed 77/100 from 52 reviews in December 2025 and 69% from 54 reviews in April 2026. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.8 out of 10.
Players have been warmer than critics. In April 2016, Hinterland reported a 99.78% approval rating from Steam users, and sales reached 5 million copies by 2021.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Long Dark en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q18085691 wikidata.org