Analysis · The Outlast Trials

The Outlast Trials makes helplessness a team sport, and pays a price

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Outlast's no-fight horror, rebuilt as a repeatable job

The Outlast Trials, from Red Barrels, keeps the series' central rule: you can't fight back. It's a first-person survival horror game where stealth is the only real way forward. This time the setting is a Cold War experiment that recruits test subjects against their will. As a prequel to Outlast (2013) and Outlast 2 (2017), it changes what surrounds that rule. You don't make one long escape through one terrible place. You run trials, each with set objectives and a grade at the end, and the grade feeds experience points and a new ability or upgrade with every level.

That's the bet. The series was built on helplessness, and now that feeling has to survive being repeated, graded and upgraded. Each part of the game either protects it or wears it down.

Four players make the dark less lonely

Trials support four-player co-op, and you can also finish the whole game solo. Co-op is where the strain on the core idea shows first. A group can split objectives and watch each other's backs, and one of the six rigs heals everyone in an area. That suits a team game, but it works against the dread of being alone in the dark.

The tools add up. Other rigs show items and enemies through walls, lay smoke-bomb mines, throw a device that stuns enemies or reinforce doors with barricades. Bricks and glass bottles can lure an enemy away or briefly stun one. None of this counts as combat, and stealth still decides most trials, but a full kit makes the player far less fragile than in the earlier games.

Outright combat isn't an option. Every tool only buys time.

Scarcity is still what scares

Trials holds onto the old fear by holding things back. Night-vision goggles are how you see in dark areas, and they run down a scarce battery supply. Early on you can carry only three items, and two more slots open up later. Traps such as noise-makers and electrified floor grates punish players who rush.

Variators add pressure: more enemies who are more alert and aggressive, and more locked and barricaded doors. The clearest sign of where the developers think the fear lives came with the Project Nostophobia update on July 1, 2025. Its variator drains goggle batteries faster, blocks rigs and removes throwable bricks, bottles and most traps. Red Barrels presented it as an attempt to make play feel more like Outlast. A mode built to bring that feeling back also admits that the default game had drifted from it.

The progression loop decides how long it lasts

Grades feed experience, levels bring new abilities and in-game currency buys cosmetics. Project Relapse, added on April 22, 2025, lets you reset a max-level character to level 1. In return you keep one ability or upgrade of your choice permanently, even through later resets, and earn a cosmetic reward. That gives players who enjoy a long climb a reason to keep going, and it shows a game built to be replayed rather than finished. It's among the most played games on Steam, which suggests the loop holds plenty of people.

Critics landed in the upper middle. The game drew "generally favorable" reviews, while the PC port got a "mixed or average" response on Metacritic. One aggregate of 21 reviews puts it at 76/100. Another, of 67 reviews as of June 23, 2026, has it at 73/100, with 60% of critics recommending it. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.5 out of 10. A clear majority approved, but a sizable minority didn't.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet