They Are Billions rewards careful planners, but critics never fully lined up
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The averages agree, the enthusiasm doesn't
Critics disagreed most about how strongly to back They Are Billions. One tally of 44 reviews, recorded on May 1, 2020, gave it an average of 75/100. The same tally also posted a figure of just 49%. A decent average next to a number that low suggests many reviewers liked the game without fully endorsing it.
The other aggregates sit in a narrow band. The PC version holds 77/100 on Metacritic. A separate count of nine reviews per version put the Windows, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One releases at 71/100 each. The critic average, computed from those critic numbers, comes to 7.3 out of 10.
The clearest praise came from David Wildgoose at Gamessport, who called it "tight and compelling." None of the scores marks it as a failure. The split is between finding it good and finding it essential.
A colony against a countdown
Each map is randomly generated: a steampunk world overrun by zombies. You plan a base, explore, gather resources and expand, all while fighting off the local infected. Eight resources need managing: gold, food, workers, wood, stone, iron, oil and energy. Buildings and units follow a tech tree, and each one draws on a different mix of materials.
The pressure comes in two forms. Small groups of zombies hit the base at random intervals. Larger hordes arrive at set times and build toward a very large "final horde". Infected settlements called Villages of Doom can be raided for resources, but raiding one can draw a swarm back to you.
The zombies vary too. Slow, decrepit ones shamble in alongside fast Harpies, tough Chubbies and an Infected Giant that is big enough to show up on the minimap. Walls, turrets, towers and traps make up the perimeter, and the mix has to change as the threats do.
Why a single breach matters so much
The game's defining rule is that infection spreads. If zombies get past the defenses and reach buildings that can't fight back, the outbreak can jump from building to building. It spreads fastest in tight or overdeveloped districts, where the damage can cascade like dominoes.
That rule probably explains the split in the scores better than any single review does. Every expansion is a bet: more workers and income, but a longer wall to hold and more buildings packed close enough to fall together. Players who enjoy that kind of planning get a steady stream of hard, meaningful choices. Players who would rather learn by trial and error may find that one mistake late in a map undoes a long stretch of careful building.
Plan the layout before you plan the army. In this game, the gap between buildings is part of the defense.
One design choice helps a lot. Although it is a real-time strategy game, you can pause at any moment to plan and give several orders at once. The tension comes from the design, not from how fast you can click.
Who it suits, and which version
This is a single-player game for people who like holding a line. If you enjoy designing a tight perimeter, stretching thin resources and watching a defense hold under a scheduled assault, Gamessport's "tight and compelling" fits. If you want multiplayer, quick skirmishes or a game that forgives sloppy expansion, the lukewarm half of the reviews is the better guide.
The game reached Steam Early Access in December 2017 with only a survival mode. A campaign called "New Empire" arrived on June 18, 2019, which gives players more structure than survival maps alone. BlitWorks published the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions on July 1, 2019.
On the numbers, PC is the safer pick: 77/100 on Metacritic against 71/100 for the console versions in the other count. In Japan, the PlayStation 4 version opened as the twentieth bestselling retail game in its first week, with 3,046 copies sold. The game was also nominated for Best Spanish Development at the 2019 Titanium Awards.
Sources
- Wikipedia: They Are Billions en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q47206077 wikidata.org