Three Uncharted games, rebuilt for PS4, with the weakest one still up front
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The best praise and the sharpest complaint come from the same box
At its best, critics treated this collection as the ideal way into the series. Sam Byford at The Verge called it a "perfect primer", an easy starting point for anyone who had never touched an Uncharted game. The aggregate backs that up: 86 out of 100 across 54 reviews, which works out to a critic average of 8.6.
The sharpest criticism hits the first thing you'd play. Many critics wrote that Uncharted: Drake's Fortune, even with new graphics, has a design that doesn't hold up to modern standards. The collection opens with its weakest game, so that's the hurdle most new players will meet first.
What Bluepoint actually changed
This is a remaster, not a remake. Bluepoint Games took the single-player campaigns of the first three Naughty Dog games, from 2007, 2009 and 2011, and brought them to PlayStation 4. In each one you play Nathan Drake, a treasure hunter, through third-person shooting, platforming and puzzles in ruins around the world.
The technical work is the part critics praised most consistently:
- All three games run at 1080p and 60 frames per second.
- Cutscenes were re-rendered, with better lighting, effects, models and textures, plus ambient occlusion and motion blur the originals lacked.
- Music was reworked to support surround sound.
- New difficulty settings, a photo mode, trophies and friends leaderboards were added.
The less flashy changes may matter more. Bluepoint tried to make the three games play alike. It rebuilt Drake's Fortune's aim assist and grenades to match the sequels, adjusted Uncharted 3's camera, improved aiming in all three and remapped buttons so the controls stay the same from game to game. Moving from one game to the next shouldn't mean relearning the basics.
Uncharted 2 carries the set
Critics agreed on which game is the highlight. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves drew praise for its pacing and attention to detail, and it remains the reason many reviewers recommended the bundle. Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception came second, admired for its spectacle and cinematography.
That leaves an uneven run. The first game is a rough start, the second is the peak, and the third is the big show. If Drake's Fortune starts to drag, the critics' praise for the two sequels makes it worth pushing on, because the best material comes later.
What's missing from the package
The multiplayer modes from Uncharted 2 and Uncharted 3 aren't included. Critics also noted the lack of behind-the-scenes videos and other extra content, and many called these missed opportunities for a collection meant to celebrate the series.
What you get is three campaigns, polished and made consistent, and not much else.
For a single-player fan, that's enough. For someone hoping to revisit the online modes or dig into how the games were made, this isn't the package for it.
Where it sits in the series
The collection arrived on October 7, 2015, as a PlayStation 4 exclusive, and Byford pitched it as the way to catch up before Uncharted 4: A Thief's End. That framing still works. It puts Drake's story in order, on one console, with controls that match. Players seemed to agree: the collection had sold 5.7 million copies as of March 21, 2019.
It's rated Teen, so it suits younger teenagers who like adventure stories with gunfights.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Uncharted: The Nathan Drake Collection en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20059613 wikidata.org