Analysis · Tomb Raider

Tomb Raider's 2013 reboot makes Lara earn every climb and every kill

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A bow, a zipline and a lot of climbing

Moment to moment, Tomb Raider asks you to keep Lara Croft moving and alive. You play in third person and cross the island on footpaths, along ziplines (some already there, some you rig yourself) and up climbable tracks. Much of her movement comes from Crystal Dynamics' earlier games, with stealth added.

Fights borrow openly from Naughty Dog's Uncharted series. You can free-aim the bow or any gun Lara salvages, brawl up close, or take enemies out quietly with stealth kills. An ability called Survival Instinct highlights enemies, collectibles and the objects a puzzle hinges on, so you rarely have to wonder where to look.

Quick time events show up at regular intervals, usually at big story beats: pulling a shard of metal out of a wound, escaping a collapsing cave. They put the most dramatic moments under your thumbs and take some control out of your hands.

The story says reluctant, the combat says ruthless

The sharpest criticism wasn't about the controls. GameTrailers' Justin Speer pointed out that the story presents Lara as vulnerable and uneasy about killing, while the experience system pays you for aggressive, brutal play. For him the clash undercut her so badly that he found it hard to identify with her at all.

IGN's Keza MacDonald noticed the same gap but was more forgiving, arguing that Lara and the player both have to adapt fast to survive. Game Informer's Matt Miller pushed back further. He noted that many combat situations can be handled in several ways, including avoiding open conflict entirely. He also praised the enemies for seeming to have actual jobs on the island rather than standing around waiting to be shot.

If the gap between story and combat bothers you, take the stealth routes. Miller found the game supports them.

An island built for coming back

The structure is hub-and-spoke: camps link the regions of one island, and you can return to earlier areas. Experience comes from hunting, exploring, fighting and completing in-game challenges, and it buys skill upgrades such as carrying more arrows and ammunition. Salvage collected around the island goes into upgrading and customizing weapons. Better gear arrives as the story moves on, since most items are tied to plot events.

Beyond the main story there are side quests and optional challenge tombs, which fit the old series name. GamesRadar's Ryan Taljonick said the areas never feel like a rehash of each other and called the pacing unrivaled in the genre. GamesMaster praised the length and depth of the play and called the last third "spectacular", which helped earn the game a 90% score and its Gold award.

Lara gets the depth, the cast doesn't

Presentation is where the praise was most consistent. MacDonald called the game "beautifully presented", praised its characterization and gave it 9.1 out of 10, IGN's highest score for the series since the original 1996 Tomb Raider. Both hosts of the Australian show Good Game rated it 10/10. Taljonick called Lara's growth "an integral part" of the whole experience.

The people around her fare worse. Taljonick described the supporting characters as generic: rarely annoying, but not memorable. Giant Bomb gave the game four stars out of five and flagged only a tension between its tone and its action. The aggregates are steady across platforms at 85/100 for the Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 and Windows versions. The game is rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18.

Skip the multiplayer and mind which edition you buy

This was the first main-series game with multiplayer: teams of four survivors against four scavengers, five maps and three modes.

  • Team Deathmatch: the first team to win three matches takes it.
  • Private Rescue: survivors carry medical supplies to a point while scavengers chase a kill count, with a ten-minute limit.
  • Cry for Help: survivors collect batteries for defended radio beacons while being hunted.

MacDonald, Speer and Miller all found it lackluster. It took most of the game's criticism and gives no reason to buy.

The Definitive Edition for PlayStation 4 and Xbox One is the other version critics reviewed. Game Informer's Matt Helgeson liked its native 1080p graphics and noted a slightly smoother frame rate on PlayStation 4. GameZone's Matt Liebl gave it 9/10 for newcomers. The Escapist's James Stephanie Sterling liked the visual upgrade but felt the small content additions and the price only made sense for players new to the game.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet