Trace Memory pairs slick stylus puzzles with a story that ends too soon
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every move runs through the stylus
The game asks you to guide Ashley Mizuki Robbins through 3D spaces and solve puzzles, almost entirely by hand on the touchscreen. The lower screen shows an overhead view of Ashley and the room around her. You move her by tapping where she should go, by dragging the stylus across the screen, or with the D-pad. The top screen shows a pre-rendered picture of wherever she's standing, so you see a map below and a scene above.
Talking to people is just as direct: tap the talk icon next to a character to start a conversation. Some puzzles go beyond tapping and use other parts of the DS, including the microphone.
Critics liked how this felt more than anything else in the game. GamesMaster called the control scheme "absolutely brilliant" and argued that the DS-specific puzzles would make players rethink how they approach puzzles in games. Kristan Reed of Eurogamer called the interface "brilliantly implemented", and Matt Wales of Computer and Video Games called it "fantastically slick."
A camera with 36 shots and a lot of walking back
Ashley's main tool is a device called the DAS (the DTS in North America). It handles saving and loading, holds messages delivered as data cards, and lets you look over your photographs. Those photos come from an in-game camera that holds up to 36 pictures at a time. An inventory keeps items until you need them.
The puzzles built on these tools split reviewers. Jeremy Parish of 1UP.com said they were deeply unoriginal, joking that their solutions were old enough to be found on ancient clay tablets. Several other reviewers agreed, though less harshly. GamesMaster went the other way and called the DS-specific puzzles uniformly good.
The bigger complaint was backtracking. Reviewers were annoyed that some items can only be picked up after you've found a use for them, which sends you back to rooms you already searched. GamesMaster, despite its praise, warned that players who prefer action could find the puzzles linear and obscure and the constant backtracking frustrating.
If an item won't go into your inventory, the game hasn't given you a reason for it yet. Expect to come back for it.
The story and art carry the game
Where critics agreed most was on the writing and the look. Jason Hill of The Sydney Morning Herald praised a plot about love, grief, ambition and memory, backed by engaging characters. Reed said the game is structured well enough to keep you guessing. Wales singled out the "expertly paced storyline" and the light mood that runs through it.
The visuals mix two styles. GamesMaster described them as cute anime portraits set against lovely 3D environments, and Wales praised both the hand-drawn art and the detailed 3D rooms. Bethany Massimilla of GameSpot thought the 2D art was where the real detail lived.
Japanese critics were warmer than most. Famitsu gave it 35 out of 40, while Metacritic's aggregate landed at mixed or average.
Four or five hours, then little reason to return
Length is the game's clearest weakness in the reviews. Massimilla said the whole thing could be finished in a single marathon session of about four or five hours. Craig Harris of IGN called it "very, very short for an adventure game", and Wales saw little to encourage a second run. Nothing in the gameplay as described, from the single story to the fixed puzzles, suggests a reason to replay it.
Many reviewers read it as a game for younger players or as a first step into graphic adventures. PJ Hruschak of CiN Weekly noted that some critics called it "Myst for Kids". Parish suggested the audience may really be young teens like Ashley herself, and summed it up as a "safe, comfortable, middle-of-the-road" experience.
That's a fair way to set expectations. A short, kind, nicely drawn mystery with smart touch controls is worth an afternoon. It isn't worth full price for anyone who has already played many puzzle adventures.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Another Code: Two Memories en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q567957 wikidata.org