Analysis · Call of Duty: World at War

Treyarch's World War II return added co-op and Zombies but kept the old script

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A step back to World War II after Modern Warfare

World at War came out in November 2008. It's the fifth main installment of Call of Duty and the fourth set in World War II. Treyarch developed it and Activision published it, following Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare. Going back to World War II was a deliberate choice, and critics judged the game largely on whether that choice paid off.

The campaign follows two soldiers: U.S. Marine Raider Private C. Miller in the Pacific and Soviet Red Army Private Dimitri Petrenko on the Eastern Front. IGN's Jason Ocampo praised Treyarch for staging the game in the Pacific, and GameSpot's Chris Watters credited the voice work for Sergeant Roebuck and Sergeant Reznov.

What Treyarch changed

The biggest changes sit around the main game, not inside it:

  • Co-op. World at War was the first Call of Duty with co-op play, a point Xplay's Scott Alan Mariott highlighted. IGN said it gave the campaign more replay value. Each level with on-foot combat hides a "death card" by a makeshift grave, and collecting them turns on co-op cheats such as weaker enemies and a paintball mode.
  • Nazi Zombies. On the Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 and Windows versions, finishing the campaign launches "Nacht der Untoten". One to four players hold off endless waves, spend points from kills and window repairs on weapons and new parts of the map, and revive each other when they go down. Later maps added Perk-a-Colas, electro-shock traps and the Pack-a-Punch weapon upgrade.
  • A harder edge. The game shows far more blood and gore than earlier entries. 1Up.com's Anthony Gallegos thought the horror was "almost too much at times", but he also said it showed the war more accurately than the series had before. Missions are also more open-ended, with more than one way to complete an objective.

Zombies is the change that lasted. It became a regular part of the series, and it's the main reason people remember this game.

What it kept, and why some critics shrugged

Underneath, this is still Modern Warfare's game. You carry two weapons plus grenades, take guns from the fallen, and switch between standing, crouching and prone. Health comes back when you stay out of fire, and the edges of the screen glow red to warn you. The Wii version swaps in motion aiming with the Wii Remote and Nunchuk.

That familiarity is where the harshest criticism landed. Official Xbox Magazine's Ryan McCaffrey called it a "play-it-safe sequel" that felt closer to an expansion pack, and said the Pacific missions played too much like the European ones. Watters at GameSpot pointed to "well-worn source material" and mechanics that gave him déjà vu. Game Informer's Matt Bertz said the game's "short bursts" of real excitement only made the rest feel weaker.

GameSpot's verdict: World at War "achieves greatness but falls short of excellence".

The story also suffers from the game's scope. Ocampo noted that some missions jump months ahead of others, which breaks up the plot.

Multiplayer and how it has aged

Competitive play has eight modes, including Team Deathmatch and capture the flag, plus vehicles. Ground War supports teams of up to 18 players. IGN said multiplayer was "definitely an area where World at War shines", and it won MSN Multiplayer Game of the Year at the 27th Golden Joystick Awards.

Later reviews have been kinder than the launch-year complaints. The game usually lands in the top 10 when critics rank the series, and NME said it did a "surprisingly good job at being scary". NME also found the campaign's difficulty frustrating, so expect some hard stretches. Not every critic liked how it handles the war itself. The Guardian's Keith Stuart and the academic Debra Ramsay both questioned a portrayal that, in Ramsay's view, leaves out civilian suffering and shows only combat.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet