Uncharted 2 plays like a summer action movie, with a few loose jumps
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for players who want an action movie they can steer
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves was made for players who want to control a blockbuster: climbing, cover shooting and big set pieces strung along one path, with a story pulling you forward. You play as Nathan Drake, who searches for the Cintamani Stone and Shambhala with Chloe Frazer and Elena Fisher while a militia led by Serbian war criminal Zoran Lazarević hunts them. It's the second game in the Uncharted series and is set two years after Uncharted: Drake's Fortune.
For that player, critics agreed it delivered. It received a Metacritic score of 96 out of 100 and was the most critically acclaimed game of 2009. Its critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 9.6.
Where it delivers: spectacle and a steady change of pace
Critics mostly praised how much it feels like cinema. Hiawatha Bray of The Boston Globe wrote that no game had better captured "the style and rhythm of the movies." Seth Schiesel of The New York Times called it "perhaps the best-looking game" on any system. The Los Angeles Times called it "ridiculously immersive."
The game keeps that pace by switching between a few kinds of play:
- Climbing: Drake jumps between points and scales narrow ledges and wall faces.
- Cover shooting: he carries one one-handed gun, one two-handed gun and a few grenades, and can fire aimed or blind from behind corners and low walls, or shoot on the move.
- Stealth: if enemies haven't spotted him, he can knock them out with one hit from behind or pull a guard over a ledge he's hanging from.
- Puzzles: Drake's journal holds clues to the solutions, and an optional hint system can point toward the next objective.
That mix is why X-Play's Adam Sessler gave it 5 out of 5 and said it had the best single-player campaign he had played.
Where it falls short: loose controls, repeated fights and a thin plot
The complaints were minor, but several critics made them. The New York Times said its "finicky controls" could frustrate. Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell described jumps that failed even when they seemed aimed the right way. IGN called some repeated gunfights "a little aggravating" and the climbing "very linear," though it admitted the complaint felt forced.
The story is the other weak spot. Bray called the storyline trite and credited the voice cast with carrying it off. If you want a big world to explore at your own speed, this is the wrong game. The path is set, and it only works if you're happy to follow it.
The multiplayer is close to a second game
IGN said the multiplayer felt as if Naughty Dog had included "an extra game for free." Co-op lets up to three players take on Nathan and two other heroes in missions that mix gunfights, platforming and teamwork, and they can revive teammates who go down or get grabbed. Competitive play puts up to 10 players in two teams of five across six modes:
- Deathmatch, with heroes against villains
- Plunder, a capture-the-flag mode where the treasure slows its carrier and can be thrown to a teammate
- Elimination, with no respawns, where the first team to win three of five rounds takes the match
- Turf War, King of the Hill and Chain Reaction
For completionists, the campaign hides 100 treasures and one secret relic. Medals for finding them and for in-game feats earn in-game money, which you spend on concept art, game movies and cheats such as guns with infinite ammunition.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Uncharted 2: Among Thieves en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17146 wikidata.org