Analysis · Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

Uncharted 4 wins on its characters, and stumbles on its pacing

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who want a blockbuster with a heart

This is a game for people who play action games for the story, and who want to care about the people dodging the gunfire. It is the fourth main Uncharted entry, set several years after Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception. Nathan Drake has retired from treasure hunting until his brother Samuel, presumed dead, pulls him back in. With his longtime partner Victor Sullivan, they chase the long-lost treasure of Henry Avery.

For that player, it delivers almost everything. Critics gave it "universal acclaim" on Metacritic, and its critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 9.4 out of 10. Players who come for long open-ended exploration or a deep online mode will find less to hold them.

The cast is the reason to play

Critics praised the relationships more than anything else. Destructoid's Steven Hansen singled out Emily Rose as Elena for capturing the small tensions of her relationship with Nathan. Polygon's Griffin McElroy felt the chemistry between Nathan and Elena peaked here, and Giant Bomb's Dan Ryckert found the talks between Nathan and Sam "more natural than hammy." GameSpot's Mike Mahardy called the new detail about Nathan "painfully human."

The visuals drew the same kind of response. Ryckert called them the best on any console, and The Escapist's Liz Finnegan described the game as "painfully beautiful." The awards back this up: Best Narrative at the Game Awards 2016, Outstanding Achievement in Videogame Writing from the Writers Guild of America, and Best Game at the 13th British Academy Games Awards.

A grappling hook and bigger maps change the fights

The game is linear, but its maps are much larger than in earlier entries and offer several paths through each area. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner said the environments were vast enough to feel like open worlds. That space matters in combat, where the game lets you:

  • sneak past or quietly take down enemies instead of shooting;
  • swing across gaps with a grappling hook to flank a group;
  • fight up close with a reworked melee system that drops quick time events.

Enemies coordinate and react to what you do, which rewards planning. Digital Spy's Sam Loveridge liked being able to map out tactics in advance, and The Telegraph's Tom Hoggins called the gunplay "punchy and pleasing." Mahardy compared the stealth to Naughty Dog's own The Last of Us.

Where it falls short: pacing and Sam

The common complaints are about rhythm. VideoGamer.com's Steven Burns called it the best story in the series but felt padding slowed it down. USgamer's Mike Williams said an open driving level "robs the game of its pacing," and The Guardian's Keith Stuart found the repeated climbing and the strict path broke the spell.

Sam is the other sore point. GamesRadar's Leon Hurley thought the brother and his backstory crowded the plot, and Kotaku's Stephen Totilo called him "more of a plot device" than a character. Critics were also split on the big action scenes: Mahardy rated them the best in the series, while Reiner found them less exciting than in earlier games.

Expect a slower, more talkative Uncharted than the earlier ones. That is the point for some critics and the problem for others.

Multiplayer is a side dish

Online play supports up to 10 players across five modes, including capture-the-flag and deathmatch, plus a three-player co-op survival mode added in December 2016. Supernatural power-ups called Mysticals and summoned helpers called Sidekicks add some variety.

Reviews were positive but limited. IGN's Lucy O'Brien said the modes carry the series' best qualities, and McElroy found them "extremely easy to pick up on." Ryckert called it "basic" and doubted players would stay long, and Reiner ran into problems loading matches. Buy this game for the campaign. Treat the multiplayer as a bonus.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet