Unity rebuilt Assassin's Creed around one huge Paris and launched broken
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The entry that left the old consoles to Rogue
Assassin's Creed Unity is the eighth major installment in Ubisoft's series and the direct successor to 2013's Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag. Ubisoft Montreal built it on the Ubisoft Anvil engine for PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Windows only, and it came out in North America on November 11, 2014. Owners of the older consoles got Assassin's Creed Rogue on the same day instead, a separate game with story ties to this one.
That split shaped Unity's whole pitch. After Black Flag's open seas, it pulls back to a single city: late 18th-century Paris, rebuilt at roughly 1:1 scale across seven districts, plus the town of Versailles on the outskirts. IGN's Marty Sliva called the result a "proof of concept" for where the series was heading. That's a fair way to read it: a lot of new systems, shipped in rough condition.
Fencing, crowds and a skill tree changed how it plays
Unity changed more of the basic controls than most yearly sequels do:
- Combat was rebuilt with fencing as its model.
- Stealth added manual crouching and the Phantom Blade, a version of the series' Hidden Blade that also works as a silent crossbow.
- Assassinations dropped the old linear missions for a "Black Box" design. You scout a location, find entry points and distractions, and pick your own approach.
- Climbing got separate "Free-run up" and "Free-run down" commands for controlled ascents and descents.
- Crowds are much larger and throw up optional events, like chasing a pickpocket or scaring off bullies.
- Progression includes a skill tree for the first time in the series. Points go into lead character Arno Dorian's stealth, melee, ranged combat and health, alongside gear rated up to level 5.
Critics noticed most of this. GamesRadar's Louise Blain praised the overhauled free-running, the character-focused mission design and the deep customization. Destructoid's Chris Carter singled out the movement system, the crowds and the smooth animation. Even PC Gamer's Tom Senior, one of the harsher reviewers, credited the game's assassination missions and its "extraordinary setting".
What stayed the same, and where critics said it stalled
Around the new systems, the familiar open-world structure is intact. Paris is full of side content: "Paris Stories" that have you help historical figures, "Murder Mysteries" where you gather clues and question witnesses, riddle chains called "Nostradamus Enigmas", and collectibles such as chests, cockades and artifacts that pay out in gear and cosmetics.
Many critics felt too much of the old game came along with it. Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell liked the side missions but called the main mission design over-familiar, complained that free-running auto-corrected too eagerly, and summed it up as a "missed opportunity". Game Informer's Matt Miller scored it 8/10 and still said navigation and combat needed more work. IGN found the stealth unrefined and the story weak, without a strong lead. Destructoid called the story predictable and objected to co-op missions that can't be played solo.
The verdicts split on the same point: the new tools are good, but the missions that use them often aren't.
The launch is part of this game's story
Unity came out with widespread bugs and glitches, plus performance and online connectivity problems. Ubisoft Montreal CEO Yannis Mallat apologized publicly, saying bugs had diminished the game's "overall quality". Ubisoft stopped selling the season pass and Gold Edition and made the first expansion, Dead Kings, free; it adds the commune of Saint-Denis. Season pass buyers were offered one of six other Ubisoft games, but claiming it meant giving up the right to sue Ubisoft over Unity.
Launch reviews were rough. PC Gamer gave it 65/100 and called it "a failed revolution" in its current state, pointing to technical and performance problems, microtransactions and stilted combat and free-running. Joystiq gave it 2.5/5, PC World called it "a new low" for the series, and CNET said it "never really finds its footing". In February 2016, Ubisoft said it wouldn't announce any more Assassin's Creed games that year and cited the lessons of Unity.
Those reviews describe the game as it launched. None of them say how much later patches fixed, so read the technical complaints as a snapshot from 2014.
Where the scores landed
The published scores run from Joystiq's 2.5/5 at the bottom to Game Informer's 8/10 at the top, with most outlets bunched in between:
- Game Informer: 8/10
- GamesRadar: 4/5
- IGN: 7.8/10
- Destructoid and Eurogamer: 7/10 each
- PC Gamer: 65/100
- Joystiq: 2.5/5
The critic aggregate sits at 69/100 on all three platforms, which Metacritic labels "mixed or average", and the critic average computed from those aggregates is 7.1 out of 10. The game also earned D.I.C.E. Award nominations for animation, art direction and sound design, which matches what critics praised most: how Paris looks, moves and sounds. It's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Assassin's Creed Unity en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q15983778 wikidata.org