Warhammer II added four races and a map that joins both games
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The sequel built to sit beside the first game
Total War: Warhammer II is Creative Assembly's follow-up to 2016's Total War: Warhammer. Like the first game, it is set in Games Workshop's Warhammer Fantasy universe and published by Sega. It came out for Windows on September 28, 2017, and Feral Interactive brought it to macOS and Linux on November 20, 2018. It held the series' fantasy branch until Total War: Warhammer III arrived in February 2022.
It is the middle game of three, and that shapes much of what it does. It isn't trying to replace the first game. It moves the war to new lands with four new races: the Lizardmen, High Elves, Dark Elves and Skaven. Then it connects back to the original so both games can be played as one.
What stayed the same: turns on the map, real time in the field
The core loop is classic Total War. On the campaign map, you move armies, manage settlements and deal with AI-controlled factions one turn at a time. When two armies meet, the game switches to a real-time battle in which you command the troops directly.
Around that loop sit the same extras the series is known for:
- a custom battles mode for building your own fights;
- online multiplayer battles, with races from the first game also available here to players who own it;
- campaigns playable online with a second player, either co-operatively or head to head.
None of this was new for Total War, and critics didn't treat it as new. They judged the sequel on what it built on top of that foundation.
What changed: a story campaign and a sandbox of both maps
The biggest structural change is the main campaign, Eye of the Vortex. It is driven by story: each playable race gets its own narrative and cutscenes, a more directed approach than the open-ended campaigns the series usually offers. IGN and PC Gamer both praised this Great Vortex campaign. Game Informer credited Creative Assembly with removing some, if not all, of the late-game monotony that tends to drag Total War campaigns out.
Players who want the open-ended version get Mortal Empires, a combined campaign that joins the maps of both Warhammer games into one sandbox. It costs nothing extra for owners of both games, though it must be downloaded manually from Steam. Critics at Destructoid and Eurogamer pointed to the campaign's size as one of the game's strengths.
The new races were the other big talking point. IGN and PC Gamer singled out the Skaven and the game's faction mechanics. GameSpot, which scored the game 9 out of 10, praised the new races, the tactical options they bring, the tight pacing, the variety of map types and the visuals. IGN and PC Gamer also noted improvements to the interface.
Where critics found the seams
Many of the complaints are long-running Total War problems that the sequel didn't fix.
- Diplomacy. Destructoid and Eurogamer called it inconsistent, and IGN and PC Gamer had similar complaints about how AI factions negotiate.
- Battle AI. Destructoid and Eurogamer took minor issue with how enemy armies behave in the field.
- Hardware demands. Several outlets flagged how much CPU power the game needs.
- Camera and competitive play. GameSpot disliked the zoomed-in camera and the absence of several factions from competitive multiplayer.
Most critics described these as minor issues rather than reasons to skip the game. The diplomacy complaint is the one that matters most over a long campaign, because it affects every turn you're not fighting.
How the record ranks it
Aggregate scores land between 83 and 86 out of 100, and the critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 8.4 out of 10. Destructoid and Eurogamer both put it among the best games in the series. Eurogamer ranked it 10th on its Top 50 Games of 2017. PC Gamer named it Best Strategy Game of 2017 and nominated it for Game of the Year. IGN nominated it for Best PC Game and Best Strategy Game.
The game also grew after launch. The Tomb Kings and the Vampire Coast, a faction of undead pirates, arrived as paid downloadable races. Smaller paid factions brought expeditions and warbands from older races, including the Empire, Bretonnia, Greenskins, Wood Elves, Beastmen and Dwarfs. The base game is complete on its own, but owning the first game is what opens Mortal Empires, and that combined campaign is the strongest reason to pick this one up.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Total War: Warhammer II en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q29061507 wikidata.org