Analysis · Star Trek: Invasion

Warthog's Trek shooter nails the space combat but misses the Trek feel

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Praise for the shooting, doubts about the Trek

The strongest praise came from John Gaudiosi at NextGen. He called Star Trek: Invasion a "textbook example" of how to put a popular license on top of solid console gameplay, and he pointed to its original Star Trek storyline and its fun multiplayer. Starlog made the sharpest criticism even though it liked the game: it said the music lacks the feel of the franchise and the ships don't match the ones seen on television or in the films.

The two views don't really conflict. Critics agreed that the shooter underneath works. They disagreed about whether it feels like Star Trek. Settle that question for yourself before you buy it.

A space shooter built by the Colony Wars team

Warthog Games developed Invasion and Activision published it. It came out only on the PlayStation, first on June 29, 2000. The team behind it had already made the Colony Wars series, which goes a long way toward explaining why critics found the space combat so confident.

It's a deep-space shooter in the space combat simulation style. It has a single-player campaign with its own Star Trek story and a multiplayer mode. Starlog said the game "delivers big and entertains" and called the graphics "great". NextGen singled out the multiplayer as a highlight rather than an extra.

That matches the developer's background. A studio that had already shipped space combat games put that experience into a licensed game, and critics noticed.

Where the license falls short

The complaints are all about Star Trek, not about the shooting. Reviewers raised three problems:

  • Music: Starlog said the score doesn't feel like the franchise.
  • Ships: Starlog also said the vessels don't match their television and film versions.
  • Story: GamePro said the plot isn't "up to Trek standards".

GamePro summed it up by saying the game isn't an enthusiastic "Engage", but it still offers a real space-shooting challenge to fans who want more of the franchise. Starlog reached a similar conclusion: players who can get past the missing Gene Roddenberry feel should be pleased with the game.

For a Trek fan who cares about accurate ship designs and the sound of the shows, these are real costs. They hurt the atmosphere and the fan service. They don't touch the part of the game critics enjoyed most.

How the scores and recognition add up

Metacritic rated the game's reception "generally favorable", and the numbers agree:

  • 76/100 from 12 reviews, in a figure dated December 20, 2022
  • 7.3/10 across 63 ratings, in a figure dated July 11, 2021
  • 8.0 in a review published August 24, 2000

The game also got recognition beyond review scores. It was nominated for Best Action Game at the Official U.S. PlayStation Magazine 2000 Editors' Awards, which Spider-Man won. Sixteen years later, in 2016, Tom's Guide ranked it among the top ten Star Trek games. A licensed game rarely gets that kind of praise so long after release.

Critics agreed the game plays well and argued about whether it feels like Trek.

Those scores put Invasion above average but short of a classic. The gap is mostly the Trek criticism above. Critics held the game to the standard of the shows and films, and on that measure they found it lacking.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet