Analysis · The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD

Wind Waker HD puts Zelda's cartoon sea on Wii U, long voyages included

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The best play in the series, and a sea that drags

The highest praise and the sharpest complaint about The Wind Waker both came from critics who liked it a lot. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Shane Bettenhausen said its core play was "the best the series has ever had". GameSpot's Jeff Gerstmann enjoyed the brisk start but found the sailing "pretty tedious" by the last third.

Most of that commentary was written about the 2002 GameCube original. The HD release came to Wii U on September 20, 2013, and averaged 93/100 across seven critic reviews. That gives it a critic average of 9.3, computed from those critic scores.

A cartoon look that won over its doubters

Fans were wary of the cel-shaded art before release, but critics mostly came around. Several compared the animation to the films of Disney and Hayao Miyazaki, and many called it a playable cartoon. IGN's Matt Casamassina saw it as the best that cel shading and the GameCube could do. Gerstmann called the doubts "unfounded" and said the character design gave the story "emotional weight".

Awards backed this up. The original won Excellence in Visual Arts at the 2004 Game Developers Choice Awards and Outstanding Achievement in Art Direction at the 7th Annual Interactive Achievement Awards. Critics singled out the characters' expressive faces and the fine detail in each island.

Familiar Zelda structure with sharper fights

Link fights with a sword and shield, locks on to enemies, and earns items that open new areas. In one example, the grappling hook gets him through the Dragon Roost Cavern dungeon and its boss, then reaches spots elsewhere that were closed off before. Dungeons end in boss fights, and side quests include taking photos with the Picto Box, an in-game camera.

Critics said it plays a lot like Ocarina of Time, with a few upgrades they liked:

  • a camera you can move around Link
  • counterattacks during combat
  • picking up and using enemies' weapons

Game Informer's Andrew Reiner called the play "far greater, deeper" than earlier games. Edge was cooler: it said veterans of the series might find it only "'merely' brilliant" because it felt so familiar. Famitsu thought it was friendly enough for newcomers.

Why the Great Sea split critics

The world is split into 49 squares of ocean, each with an island or a chain of islands. Link sails between them on a talking boat, the King of Red Lions. The wind blows in one of eight directions, and sailing into it is slow. A baton called the Wind Waker plays the Wind's Requiem to turn the wind around. Other songs warp Link between regions or turn night into day.

Critics complained about the sailing more than anything else, mostly in the late hunt for Triforce pieces across the ocean. Edge found the sailing "convincingly organic" but said that, even with warping, much of the seafaring was dull. Casamassina called changing the wind "a tedious nuisance" and was more annoyed that its animation couldn't be skipped.

Not everyone agreed. EGM's Bettenhausen and Greg Sewart enjoyed the fighting, exploring and side quests out at sea.

Sailing is a big part of the game, so if you hate slow travel, expect it to wear on you near the end.

Easy once the hearts stack up

Low difficulty was the other common complaint. Link's health grows as he finds heart containers and container pieces, and Casamassina wrote that once he has enough of them he becomes "nearly invincible". Some critics also missed voice acting, though they praised the score and soundtrack.

The easier difficulty suits younger players. The game is rated Everyone 10+ and PEGI 7, and it is single-player only.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet