Analysis · Yoshi’s Crafted World

Yoshi's Crafted World adds depth and a flip side to every level

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A spiritual successor from the same studio

Yoshi's Crafted World is the eighth main game in the Yoshi series and the fourth made for a home console. Good-Feel developed it and Nintendo published it for the Nintendo Switch on March 29, 2019, almost two years after it was shown at E3 2017. It is the spiritual successor to Good-Feel's own Yoshi's Woolly World from 2015, and the family resemblance is plain: a handmade art style, a soft difficulty curve and a lot of things to collect.

The new game keeps that handmade feel and builds it in Unreal Engine 4, with 3D characters moving across a 2.5D stage. The bigger change is how far into that stage Yoshi can reach. That's where the game earns its place in the series.

Levels now have a front, a back and a middle distance

Earlier Yoshi games ran left to right. Here, sections of a level let Yoshi walk forward and backward into the scene, and eggs can be thrown at scenery in the foreground and the background. A craft near the camera or a present tucked far behind the path can hide a collectible, so the whole frame becomes part of the search.

Every level also has a backside, opened once the front is finished, and the goal changes:

  • Find up to three Poochy Pups and bring them to the finish line.
  • Earn one Smiley Flower for each pup returned.
  • Earn one more if you finish inside the time limit.

This is the smartest idea in the game. It doubles the use of each handmade set without simply repeating it, and the timed run adds a little of the pressure the main levels lack.

The old Yoshi loop is still the engine

Outside the depth trick, the game asks you to do what Yoshi has always done. Swallow enemies with his tongue, turn them into eggs and throw them. Flowers found in levels still open new paths on the world map. Smiley Flowers pay the toll to the Blockafellers who guard each new subworld, and collecting every one in a subworld decorates its diorama with pinwheel flowers.

The side tasks stack up from there. Blockafellers send Yoshi back into levels to hit a set number of themed souvenirs with eggs. A small Blockafeller named Sprout hides in every level after Baby Bowser is beaten, and finding him everywhere earns a costume. Paying every Smiley Flower to the big Blockafeller in Hidden Hills earns the Sundream Stone costume.

Two choices keep this from feeling like a chore list. You don't need to grab everything in one run, since collected Smiley Flowers and Red Coins show up translucent on replays. And a second player can join with their own Yoshi for the whole game, which suits a parent and child or two friends splitting the hunt.

Where critics pushed back

Reviewers praised the game's charm, its level design and its graphics, and they called its gameplay formula innovative. The two complaints that came up were the soundtrack and the lack of difficulty.

The difficulty point matters most. The game is rated Everyone and PEGI 3, and critics found it plays like it. A player who comes for a challenge will find the challenge sits in finding things, not in surviving them. The backside time limits and the full-completion goals are where the tension lives, and only players who chase them will feel it.

Treat it as a hunting game with platforming in it, not a platformer that tests your reflexes.

How it landed

Metacritic rated the reception "generally favorable," and OpenCritic found 81% of critics recommended it. In Japan, four Famitsu critics gave it 37 out of 40, with one awarding a perfect 10. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 8.1 out of 10.

It also sold. The game was the first in the Yoshi series to debut at the top of the UK all-format chart, opened at number one in Japan with 53,327 physical copies, and had reached 3.35 million units worldwide by December 2022, according to the 2023 CESA Games White Papers. Those numbers back up the critics: the crafted, front-and-back idea worked.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet