Analysis · Borderlands 2

Borderlands 2 keeps the loot loop and gives Pandora a villain worth chasing

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A sequel that fixed more than it reinvented

Borderlands 2 is Gearbox Software's 2012 follow-up to the 2009 Borderlands. 2K published it, and it returns to the planet Pandora five years after the first game. A new group of Vault Hunters joins the Crimson Raiders, a resistance of civilian survivors and guerrilla fighters, to stop Handsome Jack before he can tap the power of a new Vault.

Critics broadly agreed that it was a clear step up from the original. Game Informer's Dan Ryckert said its quality-of-life changes made it a "noticeably superior experience." The main dissent came from 1Up.com's Bob Mackey, who felt the changes were enough to earn the number 2 but left the basic experience mostly as it was. Both readings hold up. This is the first game's formula, tuned rather than rebuilt. Its critic average, computed from critic aggregates, is 8.6 out of 10, and by 2025 it had sold over 30 million units, more than any other game in the franchise.

The loot loop is unchanged, and that's the appeal

Like its predecessor, it's a first-person shooter with role-playing systems layered on top. Guns come from vendors, fallen enemies and containers, in six types: pistols, submachine guns, assault rifles, shotguns, sniper rifles and rocket launchers. A procedural system generates endless variations. Each in-game manufacturer gives its guns a distinct character, a color scale marks rarity, and some weapons add elemental damage. You can't equip everything you pick up, so managing your inventory never stops.

Eurogamer's Christian Donlan liked how distinct the manufacturers feel, and Destructoid's Allistair Pinsof noted that different guns push you toward different ways of fighting. GameSpot's Chris Watters called the gunplay "solid" and "satisfying."

Each of the four classes has one Action Skill on a cooldown:

  • Axton, the Commando, summons a turret.
  • Maya, the Siren, traps enemies in a sphere of energy.
  • Zer0, the Assassin, turns invisible and leaves a decoy.
  • Salvador, the Gunzerker, dual-wields weapons for a short time.

Every class has three skill trees. Finishing the campaign opens True Vault Hunter Mode, a New Game Plus with tougher enemies, better odds of rare loot and a level cap of 50. Watters had one complaint here that's worth weighing: he found that combat felt largely the same across all four classes.

The writing and Handsome Jack are what changed

The biggest shift is in tone and setting. Watters described Pandora as a "vibrant, living place," a contrast with the first game's desolate desert. Pinsof called the script the funniest and cleverest since Portal 2 and noted that nearly every character gets a standout comic line. Ryckert ranked the game's humor among the best in the industry.

Handsome Jack drew the most praise. Ryckert found him "entertaining" and Pinsof called him "lovable." GamesRadar's Sterling McGarvey argued that Jack keeps the story compelling even when the campaign sags. VentureBeat's Mike Minotti singled out the writing for Claptrap, Tiny Tina and Ellie. Not everyone was won over. IGN's Anthony Gallegos called the plot "predictable," though still better than the original's, and Minotti felt the steady stream of jokes undercut the serious moments.

Where it pads and stalls

The most common complaint is length without substance. Polygon's Arthur Gies called the quest design some of the worst of its kind and felt that filler was there to stretch the game. McGarvey also called the campaign bloated. Pinsof found the mission design conservative for a game with such loud characters. Other complaints:

  • The opening disappointed both Gies and PC Gamer's Tom Francis. Francis said it "strips the game" of what makes it good.
  • Minotti pointed to reused dungeons and some overpowered enemies.
  • Critics saw driving as a missed opportunity.

Built for co-op, rougher on other hardware

You can play solo, in offline splitscreen or in online co-op. Donlan and Ryckert liked how the four classes complement each other. Minotti praised how easy it is for friends to join a session, and Watters pointed to item trading, difficulty scaling and better loot as reasons to play together. There are two catches. Pinsof noted that shared loot leaves a veteran with low-tier drops when playing alongside a newcomer. McGarvey found that respawn stations are far apart, so a player who dies often has a long walk back to the group.

Choose your version carefully. IGN gave the PlayStation Vita port a 5.4 out of 10, citing weaker visuals, erratic performance and two-player multiplayer instead of four. IGN's Steven Petite called the PlayStation VR version a "decent adaptation" but missed multiplayer and disliked the motion controls. On PC, the VR release had technical problems and only 45% of player reviews on Steam were positive.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet