Dreams turns a PlayStation 4 into a game studio, and critics rewarded it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Awards for originality, and one pointed comparison
The strongest praise for Dreams came in awards as well as scores. At Gamescom 2019 it won Most Original Game, Best PlayStation 4 Game and Best of Gamescom 2019, and MCV/Develop named it Gameplay Innovation of the Year. OpenCritic reported that 96% of critics recommended it, and Metacritic summed up its reviews as "generally favorable". The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 9.1 out of 10.
The sharpest note came from Vice, which compared Dreams to Newgrounds, a website long known for hosting Adobe Flash "oddities". That reads partly as affection. It also names the catch: a platform built on what players make will be as uneven as what players make. Very little else in the reception pushes back, so the case against Dreams rests more on what kind of thing it is than on complaints critics made.
A creation tool first, a game second
Dreams is a game creation system from Media Molecule, published by Sony Interactive Entertainment for the PlayStation 4 in February 2020. Players make games, audiovisual pieces and game assets, then share them or let others remix them into their own work.
Everything runs through an "imp", a small cursor you steer like a mouse pointer. You can move it by tilting and turning a DualShock 4 or PlayStation Move controller, or with the two analog sticks. The imp grabs and pulls objects, builds new items and characters, and can possess a character inside a dream so you control it directly. You can also customize the imp itself.
The game is split into six sections:
- DreamSurfing, for playing what others have published
- DreamShaping, for building
- Highlights
- Profile
- Community Jam
- Homespace
That structure tells you where the weight sits. Most of Dreams is about making, sharing and finding, not a set campaign.
What you play depends on other players
DreamSurfing is the closest thing to a traditional play mode. Players, whom the game calls "Dreamers", publish their work to the "Dreamiverse", and you browse it in playlists such as "Mm Picks", "New Trending Dreams" and "New Recommendations For You". A feature called Autosurf drops you into random dreams from a playlist, and you can leave a thumbs up or a comment on anything you try.
The range is wide. A dream might be a game, a piece of music, a sculpture or an art showcase. Many hide collectible Prize Bubbles that give you new Elements to use in your own projects, a system that works much like the Prize Bubbles in the LittleBigPlanet series. Playing and building feed each other.
Media Molecule's own contribution on the play side is Art's Dream, a game made inside Dreams and found in DreamSurfing. Beyond that, quality is up to the community. This is where Vice's Newgrounds comparison bites: inspired work sits next to rough experiments, and the curated playlists do the sorting.
Why critics saw more than a toy box
Tortoise Media placed Dreams at the front of a broader shift, describing a trend toward the "democratisation of game development" that puts making games within reach of ordinary players. That's the real argument for it. Most games give you something finished. Dreams gives you the tools that produced its own showcase game and asks what you'll do with them.
Dreams is best judged by what it lets you make, not by any single thing it contains.
That framing also explains who will bounce off it. If you want a long, authored story with a clear end, Dreams can't promise that, because so much of what's on offer comes from strangers. If you've ever sketched a level on paper, written a tune or wanted to see how games are put together, the awards and the 96% recommendation rate point the same way: this is a rare, generous toolkit. It's rated Teen and supports both single-player and multiplayer play.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Dreams (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q22000976 wikidata.org