Analysis · EA SPORTS FC™ 24

EA Sports FC 24 keeps FIFA's football and pushes Ultimate Team harder

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The idea is continuity, not reinvention

EA Sports FC 24 rests on one idea: keep the football and change the name. It's the first game in the EA Sports FC series and the 31st in EA Sports' long run of football simulations. It arrived after Electronic Arts's partnership with FIFA ended with FIFA 23. EA Vancouver and EA Romania built it on the Frostbite engine, and it launched on 29 September 2023 across Switch, PlayStation 4 and 5, Windows, Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S.

Critics agreed on what that meant. IGN's Andrew McMahon and GameSpot's Richard Wakeling both gave it 7/10. Both called it much like earlier installments, with some additions but mostly incremental improvements. So the real question isn't whether this is a new kind of football game. It's whether the changes on top of a familiar base are worth paying for again.

On the pitch, the small changes add up

The improvements show up most clearly in matches. Both IGN and GameSpot praised the added realism and smoothness of HyperMotion, along with the updated graphics and animations.

PlayStyles got the strongest praise. McMahon called them "genuinely impressive" for how many players' traits they capture. He also said that adding them to custom players "[makes] a world of difference". Wakeling found actions tied to a player's PlayStyle much more satisfying to pull off.

The weak spot is the AI. It was promoted as an upgrade on the FIFA games, but both critics called it disappointing, especially in goal. That fits the continuity idea: the surface moved forward and the underlying behavior mostly didn't.

Ultimate Team grew, and so did the asking price

Ultimate Team changed the most. Critics praised the new Evolutions mode, and reviewers welcomed women's players into the mode because they added more players and more ways to build a squad.

The mode also produced the game's worst headlines. The Elite Season Opener Pack, worth the equivalent of $30, went on sale during an early access period players had already paid extra to join, and its contents were judged sub-par. Wakeling wrote that it was "more than a little dystopian" to keep asking paying customers for more money. In February 2024, loyalty packs meant to reward long-time players still cost up to the equivalent of $20 each. Separately, EA cut the odds on a Team of the Year challenge after it handed out more Lionel Messi cards than intended, which upset players who had already bought the card with in-game coins.

Players review-bombed the game early on. They complained that it changed too little from the last one and pointed to bugs, including an Ada Hegerberg card that ran away from the ball.

Career Mode is where standing still turned into going backwards

Not every mode benefited from the light-touch approach. McMahon and Wakeling both called the Career Mode changes harmful, which is a harsher result than "incremental". McMahon liked the nostalgic VOLTA street mode, but it doesn't make up for a weaker Career Mode if that's where you spend your time.

On Switch, it depends on what you compare it to

The Switch version split critics more sharply than any other part of the game:

  • Nintendo Life, 8/10: Chris Scullion praised its near-parity with other consoles. He noted that Ultimate Team on Switch had previously been a copy of FIFA 17's version and now had seven years of features added back. He called it "the best football game ever released on a Nintendo system."
  • IGN, 4/10: McMahon compared it with the other console versions instead. Without HyperMotion, PlayStyles were limited, and he likened the look and play to something from 2006. He still called it the best handheld football game.
  • Pocket Tactics, 8/10: Connor Christie found it fluent despite the lower frame rate.

Scullion thought VOLTA suited a portable console well. McMahon found it hard to get into a game at all, because the mode needs online players and few Switch owners were playing it.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet