Analysis · EA Sports FC 25

EA Sports FC 25 won a Game Awards trophy and still split its critics

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A football simulation for one player or many

EA Sports FC 25 is a football simulation for one player or for many, and it's rated Everyone. The published summaries of critics' reviews say almost nothing about how a match plays from kickoff to the final whistle. They don't describe the passing, the shooting or the defending, so there's no basis for judging how the play feels.

The scope is clear, though. EA Vancouver and EA Romania developed the game and Electronic Arts published it. It came out worldwide on September 27, 2024, on six platforms:

People who pre-ordered the Ultimate Edition could start playing on September 20, 2024, a full week before everyone else. That matters most if you play online, because early buyers get a head start.

The score depends on which number you read

The average scores look comfortable. The recommendation rate is cooler. Here is how the critic numbers line up:

  • Metacritic: 77/100 from 32 reviews, listed the same for every platform. Its summary still called the PlayStation 5 reviews "generally favorable" and the Xbox Series X/S reviews "mixed or average".
  • OpenCritic, March 5, 2025: 63% of 93 critics recommended the game.
  • OpenCritic, November 5, 2025: 76/100 from 91 reviews.

The critic average of 7.7 out of 10 is calculated from those aggregates with a published formula. It isn't a separate verdict.

The gap between the numbers tells the story. An average of 76 or 77 out of 100 means most critics found the game solid. A 63% recommendation rate means more than a third of them stopped short of telling readers to buy it. That pattern usually means a game is competent but hard to get excited about, and it's the main reason to wait rather than buy now.

An award winner that disappointed its own publisher

Industry juries liked FC 25 more than the review averages suggest. It won Best Sports / Racing Game at The Game Awards 2024 and was nominated for Sports Game of the Year at the 28th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.

Sales sent mixed signals. In January 2025, Electronic Arts reported that the game had underperformed financially and lowered its financial outlook for the year. Yet as of July 2025, the sales tracker GSD listed EA Sports FC 25 as Europe's best-selling PC and console game of 2025.

Lots of people bought it, just not as many as its publisher planned for.

Both facts can be true. A game can top a regional chart and still fall short of a large company's forecast. For a buyer, the takeaway is simple: FC 25 has a big player base, and its critics and its publisher both stopped short of calling it a big step forward.

How long it holds up, and who should pay full price

The game's staying power is its strongest point. It's the second game under the EA Sports FC name and the 32nd in EA Sports' long-running football line, and it still ranks among the most played games on Steam. If you want opponents to play against and a game your friends already own, that crowd counts for a lot.

What critics didn't do was give a clear reason to upgrade. A 63% recommendation rate isn't a mandate. If you already own an earlier entry in the series and you're happy with it, nothing in the reviews says you're missing out.

Buy at full price only if you play online every week and want to keep up with everyone else. Everyone else can wait: the game will play the same at a lower price.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet