Analysis · Farpoint

Farpoint scored a 71 yet only 25% of critics recommended it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A 71 average next to a 25% recommendation rate

Farpoint holds a 71% on Metacritic, which counts as generally positive. OpenCritic, counting 53 reviews, recommends it from only 25% of critics. Both numbers describe the same set of reviews.

The scores explain the gap. IGN gave it 7.5 out of 10. GameSpot, Game Informer and Destructoid each gave it a 7. Almost no one disliked Farpoint, and few loved it enough to call it a must-play. The critic average of 7.0, computed from those critic aggregates, sits in that same zone of respect without enthusiasm.

The dispute came down to what critics measured it against. Judged as a PlayStation VR game, it impressed them. Judged as a shooter, it mostly didn't.

Why VR players came away happy

Farpoint is a first-person shooter set on a hostile alien planet, built by Impulse Gear in Unreal Engine 4 and published by Sony Interactive Entertainment for PlayStation VR on May 16, 2017. It supports the PS VR Aim Controller, a gun-shaped peripheral, and that pairing drew the warmest praise.

IGN credited its "fantastic gunplay" and freedom of movement with setting it apart from most VR shooting galleries.

That comparison matters. Many early VR shooters kept players rooted in place and sent targets at them. Farpoint lets you move through its levels, and critics treated that as a real step forward. Game Informer called it "a sound VR experience" even while saying it wouldn't move the needle as a shooter.

Players and award juries agreed. It debuted at number two on the UK sales charts, the highest-charting VR-required game there, and sold 17,100 copies in its first week in Japan. It won the PlayStation VR Award at the PlayStation Awards 2017 and PlayStation VR Game of the Year at Road to VR's 2017 awards.

Why shooter fans held back

The complaints weren't about how Farpoint plays. They were about what surrounds the shooting. GameSpot noted that it changes gears in surprising ways and stretches its gunplay by remixing levels, then concluded it feels "more like a proof of concept" than a game that pushes the envelope on its own terms.

Destructoid went after the world itself, arguing that the technical advances aren't backed by a setting that does them justice. Take away the headset and the novelty of aiming a physical rifle, and critics saw an ordinary shooter on a familiar alien planet.

Remixed levels are the clearest warning sign. Reusing spaces to stretch the gunplay suggests the campaign has less variety than its length implies.

Who should pick it up

The split in the reviews works as a buying guide:

  • PlayStation VR owners with the Aim Controller are the audience critics praised it for. Free movement and a physical gun are the reason to buy it.
  • PlayStation VR owners without the controller can still play it. Critics' praise centered on the gunplay, though, so expect less of what made it stand out.
  • Players who want co-op in VR get online cooperative play on top of the single-player campaign.
  • Players who want a great shooter first should look elsewhere. Even the positive reviews said it doesn't advance the genre.

It is rated Mature 17+, and it needs a PlayStation 4 with PlayStation VR.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet