Hidden Agenda drew middling scores and few champions, so bring friends
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The scores sit in the middle, and the enthusiasm sits lower
Hidden Agenda's critics didn't split into fans and haters. They clustered around "fine." Metacritic summed up the reception as "mixed or average." One aggregate of 44 reviews, tallied on March 23, 2018, put the average at 68/100, and another outlet scored it 6/10. The critic average, which is computed from those critic numbers, comes out at 6.8.
The same 44-review aggregate also shows a much lower figure: 28%. Read next to a 68 average, that gap suggests a game that rarely earned a harsh score but rarely won anyone over either. Reviewers seem to have agreed it worked well enough. Far fewer agreed it was worth recommending.
That kind of reception usually means the game's appeal depends heavily on how you play it. Hidden Agenda is a clear case.
A serial-killer case decided by quick reactions
Supermassive Games developed Hidden Agenda on Unreal Engine 4, and Sony Interactive Entertainment published it for the PlayStation 4. It came out on October 24, 2017 in the United States and on November 22, 2017 in Europe.
The story follows two people working the case of a serial killer known as The Trapper:
- Becky Marney, a homicide detective played by Katie Cassidy
- Felicity Graves, a district attorney played by Christy Choi and Ashley Voom
It plays from a third-person view, and quick time events push the plot one way or the other, up to whether a character lives or dies. It's listed as both an action-adventure game and an interactive film. That second label fits better: you shape the story by making choices and hitting prompts, not by exploring or fighting.
Built for a room full of phones, not one player
What sets Hidden Agenda apart is PlayLink. Instead of passing a controller around, everyone in the room joins on an Android or iOS smartphone and votes on what happens next. Decisions become small arguments, and the story goes wherever the majority pushes it.
Competitive mode adds the hook the game is named after. At some point, one player gets a secret objective, a hidden agenda, and has to steer the group toward it while everyone else tries to stop it. That's where the game turns from a shared movie into a social game, closer to a party bluffing game than to a solo thriller.
A choice-driven thriller lives or dies on its cast and plot. A party game lives or dies on the people playing it. Hidden Agenda is trying to be both.
That double identity probably explains the middling numbers. Judged as a story to play alone, it has to compete with games built entirely around that. Judged as a group game, its best feature only works if you have three or four people, their smartphones and a free evening.
Who should actually play it
The record points to one clear audience: people who already host game nights and want something that puts a story at the center instead of a board. The phone voting means no one needs a second controller, and the secret-objective mode gives the group a reason to suspect each other.
Solo players have a weaker case. You still get the Trapper case and its life-or-death prompts, but you lose the voting and the betrayal, which are what the game is built around. If what you want is Supermassive's style of branching story on your own, the studio has made plenty of others, from Until Dawn in 2015 to The Quarry in 2022.
Price matters here. A game critics called average, and one you'll likely play only a few times with the same group, is easier to justify when it's on sale.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Hidden Agenda (2017 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q30612014 wikidata.org