Outward makes you a commoner, and critics couldn't agree that's fun
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A 64 average hides how few critics said yes
Look only at the averages and Outward seems like a safe, middling pick. One aggregator puts it at 66/100 from 13 reviews, a figure listed for the PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox One and Windows versions. Another showed 64/100 from 41 reviews as of June 19, 2019. Metacritic's label for the reception was "mixed or average."
The number that stands out comes from that second aggregator on the same date: only 21% of 43 critics recommended the game. A 64 average next to a 21% recommend rate means a lot of reviewers landed just below the line. They saw something worth respecting and still wouldn't tell readers to buy it.
That gap is the most useful thing to know about Outward. The record doesn't break down which features cost it those recommendations. Its design, though, points to a likely answer: almost everything that sets it apart is something a player will either love or resent.
You aren't the hero, and the game means it
Most open world fantasy role-playing games cast you as the chosen one. Outward makes you a commoner. On top of standard action role-playing combat, you have to manage warmth, hunger, fatigue and thirst. Your character can catch a cold, pick up a disease or get indigestion.
For some players, that upkeep is the point. It makes a walk between towns feel like a trip you had to plan. For others it's a list of chores that gets between them and the adventure. A design this committed to friction tends to produce reviews that say "interesting" and stop short of "recommended," which matches the numbers above.
No reloads, and failure sticks
The sharpest design choice is the save system. Outward only auto-saves. You can't make a manual save, and you can't go back to an earlier one after a death or a bad decision.
Losing a fight doesn't simply send you to a game over screen. Depending on the situation, enemies might imprison you or someone might carry you back to safety. Quests can end several ways, and the results are permanent: a character might be talked into staying with a faction, or an important city can be destroyed for good if you fail to kill certain characters.
Progress is slow by design, too:
- Spells were deliberately made hard to obtain.
- Skills and stat increases come from finishing quests for characters or paying trainers.
If you reload a save every time a quest goes wrong, Outward is going to frustrate you. If you've always wished your choices couldn't be taken back, this is the game built for that.
Co-op is the strongest argument for it
Outward supports multiplayer online and local split-screen. That changes the pitch. Hunger, cold and capture read differently when a friend is dealing with them next to you, and a bad outcome becomes a story you share instead of a loss you take alone.
It also found its audience despite the reviews. The game has sold over one million copies, and it shows up among the most played games on Steam. It came out in March 2019 on PlayStation 4, Windows and Xbox One, reached Google Stadia in November 2020, and arrived on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X/S with the Definitive Edition in May 2022. The game was made by the Canadian studio Nine Dots in Unity and published by Deep Silver.
So Outward is better understood as a narrow game than a mediocre one. The critics who held back were probably reacting to the same features its fans came for. Decide based on those features, not the average score.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Outward en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q62128996 wikidata.org