Analysis · Payday 3

Payday 3 has strong heists, too few of them and a rough online launch

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The heists are the reason to play

Payday 3 is a cooperative first-person shooter about heists: robberies that a crew plans and carries out together. Critics agreed that these jobs are the best thing about it. Travis Northup at IGN said the cooperative heists were "off to a strong start," and Giovanni Colantonio at Digital Trends called the launch heists "a strong batch."

Neither critic thought the heists were new. Colantonio wrote that the game doesn't change Payday 2's formula much. Payday 2 fans will know the rhythm right away. That also means they get little they couldn't already play in the older game.

Not enough jobs at launch

Critics who liked the heists still felt the game was short on content. Northup put it this way: the vault was "a bit bare" at release. Vikki Blake at Eurogamer was harsher. She called Payday 3 "a shallow shooter" that gives too little "bang for your ill-gotten buck."

Digital Trends described Payday 3 as a live service shooter, a game designed to keep adding content after release. That helps explain the small launch lineup, but it doesn't change what buyers got on day one. Critics judged the game on the jobs that were available, and most found there weren't enough.

Critics liked how the heists play. Their complaint was that there weren't many of them.

Online-only meant a broken first week

Payday 3 needs an internet connection to play. When it launched on September 21, 2023, on PlayStation 5, Windows and Xbox Series X/S, the servers failed under the rush of players. The game was close to unplayable, and the outages lasted for days. Starbreeze said more than 1.3 million players showed up at launch.

Big launches often run into server trouble. For Payday 3 it mattered more than usual because the game has no offline mode. Even players who only wanted to play a heist on their own could not reach the game until the servers recovered.

The record says little about how the game looks or sounds. It runs on Unreal Engine 4 and is rated PEGI 18. None of the critics quoted here made the presentation a main point, either as praise or as a complaint.

The crowd left quickly

A co-op shooter needs other people to play with, so the player count affects how much the game is worth. Payday 3 sold well at first: in September 2023 it was the fifth best-selling game in the United States and the sixth in the United Kingdom. One month after launch, its Steam player count had dropped so far that Payday 2 had 10 times as many players online at the same time.

Things got worse for the business from there:

  • In November 2023, Embracer Group said the game had missed its sales expectations.
  • In February 2024, Starbreeze said sales and player activity were well below expectations.
  • Starbreeze replaced its CEO in March 2024, and again in May 2024.
  • In September 2024, game director Miodrag Kovačevićas was removed ahead of the game's second year.
  • In November 2024, acting CEO Mats Juhl said the game "hasn't made any profits."
  • In May 2025, Starbreeze said it had bought the publishing rights back from Plaion.

Starbreeze keeping the rights and appointing new leaders suggests it still backs the game. It doesn't show that the player count has recovered.

What the scores add up to

Critic scores put Payday 3 in the middle. An aggregate of 29 reviews came to 65/100 on PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X and Series S, and Windows. Another aggregate stood at 63/100 from 83 reviews in December 2023. By January 31, 2024, a figure from 91 reviews read 26%. In Japan, four Famitsu critics gave it 30 out of 40 combined.

The critic average of 6.4 out of 10 is calculated from these critic aggregates. It fits what critics wrote: the core heists work, but the game launched with too little content and a weak start for an online-only game.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet